Earth Science News  





. A Year Of Added Life More Valuable For The Young

Despite studies that suggest that a year of life added for a 15-year old should receive 2 to 3 times more weight than a year of life added for an 80-year old, standard economic methods used to direct resources do not account for age or the fact that societies, as they become richer, tend to value health more over time. The U-M study suggests policy makers must rethink how healthcare dollars and other resources are used across age group, by adjusting economic formulae to better reflect society's values.
by Staff Writers
Ann Arbor MI (SPX) Mar 08, 2007
Many important health policy issues, such as the allocation of avian flu vaccine in a pandemic or mandatory HPV vaccinations for young women, require policy makers to decide healthcare priorities for different age groups. Yet economic methods used to allocate health care dollars and other resources may substantially undervalue childhood interventions, a new University of Michigan study suggests.

This undervaluation occurs despite evidence that people place as much as three times greater value on health gains for children and adolescents, relative to adults or seniors.

University of Michigan's Daniel Eisenberg, assistant professor in the School of Public Health, and Dr. Gary Freed, director of the Child Health Evaluation and Research Unit in the Division of General Pediatrics, reviewed a series of separate survey studies that show society favors early childhood intervention.

Despite studies that suggest that a year of life added for a 15-year old should receive 2 to 3 times more weight than a year of life added for an 80-year old, standard economic methods used to direct resources do not account for age or the fact that societies, as they become richer, tend to value health more over time.

The U-M study suggests policy makers must rethink how healthcare dollars and other resources are used across age group, by adjusting economic formulae to better reflect society's values.

"Our paper reviews recent studies related to how society values health gains for people of different ages," Eisenberg said. "These studies generally suggest that health gains for people at younger ages should receive higher priority than equivalent health gains for older people. When we incorporate these values into standard cost-effectiveness analysis methods, then interventions for young people, such as recently developed vaccines for HPV or meningitis, look significantly more appealing from a cost-effectiveness perspective."

Eisenberg and Freed illustrated the findings with examples of recently evaluated vaccine interventions. The paper, "Reassessing How Society Prioritizes the Health of Younger People," will appear in the March/April edition of Health Affairs, available March. 6.

"This study illustrates that the way we have been performing cost-effectiveness studies devalues the effect of interventions on children relative to adults and seniors," said Freed, who also has an appointment in the school of public health.

"As a nation, we must take a fresh look at how we measure the benefit of interventions focused on children. Likely, they represent the best investment we can make in our country's health now and in the future."

The paper does not suggest that society should divert health care from adult and senior programs, Eisenberg stressed. It is unknown how often economic methods such as cost-effectiveness analysis are actually used to allocate health care dollars---many other factors contribute to the decision making process, particularly in a decentralized health system such as ours, he said. Rather, the study suggests that age should be accounted for in future economic calculations and that the evidence on societal values for this issue should continue to be developed.

Email This Article

Related Links
Medicine at University of Michigan
All About Human Beings and How We Got To Be Here
The science and news of Epidemics on Earth

Researchers Reconstruct Spread Of Bird Flu From China
Washington (AFP) Mar 06, 2007
US researchers have reconstructed the evolution of avian flu and its spread over the past decade from its first origins in southern China, according to a new study. The team from Irvine University in California combined genetic and geographic data for the H5N1 virus, identifying many of the migration routes through which the strains spread across Asia and then around the globe.

.
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
  



  • Thousands Flee Indonesia Landslide Fearing New Calamity
  • Death And Destruction After Powerful Indonesia Quake
  • Indian Army Airlifts Thousands Stranded On Kashmir Highway
  • Conflicting Signals Can Confuse Rescue Robots

  • EU Summit Seeks Unity On Tackling Global Warming
  • Wet Desert Of India Drying Out
  • The U.N.'s War On Global Warming
  • Banning New Coal Power Plants Will Slow Warming

  • Satellite Scientists Set To Descend On Hobart
  • CSIRO Imagery Shows Outer Great Barrier Reef At Risk From River Plumes
  • Scientists Gear Up For Envisat 2007 Symposium
  • ITT Passes Critical Design Review for GOES-R Advanced Baseline Imager

  • Progress Made in Biomass-to-Biofuels Conversion Process
  • China Bans New Small Coal-Based Power Generators
  • Unlocking The Secrets Of High-Temperature Superconductors
  • Iran Seeks Closer Naval Ties With Oil-Starved India

  • A Year Of Added Life More Valuable For The Young
  • Researchers Reconstruct Spread Of Bird Flu From China
  • Two Weapons Ready For AIDS Fight
  • Troubling Trends In AIDS Cases

  • Some Corals Might Be Able To Fight The Heat
  • Why Do Birds Migrate
  • Fish, Trees, Cuddly Mammal Up For Protection From Human Trade
  • Scientists Invent Real-Life Tricorder For Chemical Analysis

  • Asian Pollution Linked To Stronger Pacific Storm System
  • As An Economy Blossoms An Ancient Capital Suffocates
  • Canada's Oil Sands To Keep Polluting
  • UN Forum Makes Limited Progress On Mercury Emissions

  • Could Baby Boomers Be Approaching Retirement In Worse Shape Than Their Predecessors
  • Time For TV Detox
  • DNA Study Explains Unique Diversity Among Melanesians
  • First Direct Electric Link Between Neurons And Light-Sensitive Nanoparticle Films Created

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement