Earth Science News  





. Birth Rate And Competition Were Major Reasons For Past Hominid Extinctions

Australopithecus/Paranthropus boisei. Paranthropus boisei, a Pleistocene hominid, thrived around 2.5 million years ago, but disappears from the fossil record a million years ago. Paranthropus boisei became extinct when it was unable to compete with other mammals. A specialized feeder, Paranthropus boisei dined on hard objects like seeds, tubers and bones. While it had a variety of food sources, they all required the crunching, grinding force of its teeth.

Unfortunately, bush pigs and hyenas had great grinding and crushing teeth, too, and went after the same food. Paranthropus could not compete because it produced one offspring a year at most, while the others had large litters and could increase their populations at a much faster rate. Paranthropus simply could not compete reproductively and could not alter its choice of food.

by Staff Writers
University Park PA (SPX) Feb 22, 2007
Modern human mothers are probably happy that they typically have one, maybe two babies at a time, but for early hominids, low birth numbers combined with competition often spelled extinction. "The lineages of primates have some traits that make it hard for them to respond to rapid perturbations in the environment," says Dr. Nina G. Jablonski, professor of anthropology and department head at Penn State.

"Through time we see a lot of lineages become extinct when environments where the species are found become highly seasonal or unpredictable."

Primates evolved in the Paleocene and Eocene when worldwide climate was less seasonal. The beneficial environment allowed primates to evolve as relatively brainy animals that reproduce slowly. However, when climate changed so that tropical forests shrunk and the environment became patchy, many species including primate species became extinct.

"While past primate populations moved with the forest, early hominid cultures 2.5 million years ago show signs of the ability to live in marginal areas and live on more dynamic, seasonal landscapes," Jablonski told attendees today (Feb. 16) at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in San Francisco.

Through time, the human lineage evolved to fill a wide variety of ecological niches, but those species that filled narrow environments, were less able to withstand the effects of climate change. Paranthropus boisei, a Pleistocene hominid, thrived around 2.5 million years ago, but disappears from the fossil record a million years ago. Paranthropus boisei became extinct when it was unable to compete with other mammals.

A specialized feeder, Paranthropus boisei dined on hard objects like seeds, tubers and bones. While it had a variety of food sources, they all required the crunching, grinding force of its teeth. Unfortunately, bush pigs and hyenas had great grinding and crushing teeth, too, and went after the same food. Paranthropus could not compete because it produced one offspring a year at most, while the others had large litters and could increase their populations at a much faster rate. Paranthropus simply could not compete reproductively and could not alter its choice of food.

"We find that the early members of the genus Homo who succeeded were super ecological opportunists," says Jablonski. "They would eat vegetation and scavenge, kill small animals and forage."

Cultural adaptations helped these opportunists to take advantage of whatever food was available. But culture did not seem to help the Neandertal. Tremendously successful from about 200 to 50 thousand years ago, they suffered a gradual decrease and extinction from about 30 to 26 thousand years ago.

"Neandertal was extremely adept culturally," says Jablonski. "They had big brains, a wide variety of tools and were extremely successful as active, aggressive hunters of large game. We see evidence of hunting, kill sites, butchery and even herding off cliffs. We find thrusting spears and butchering knives."

The Neandertal encountered increasing environmental seasonality with longer cold seasons and shorter periods of warm weather. Leading up to and during the last glacial maximum about 18,000 years ago, the grassy plains disappeared, taking with them the animals that relied on large expanses of grass for grazing. These animals were the prime food source for Neandertal.

At the same time, modern Homo sapiens experienced the same reduction in large animal game, but switched to also fishing, snaring small mammals like rabbits and capturing turtles and birds.

"Rather than being a specialized large mammal predator, modern humans would eat anything they could get their hands on. They eked out a living even if it meant eating grasshoppers or whatever," says Jablonski. "Even with this, modern humans barely hung on from 12 to 16,000 years ago.

"Why did Neandertal not adapt culturally?" she asks. "Why did they not start eating bunnies? They did begin fishing."

Jablonski believes that competition from modern humans was already too strong. The environment was marginal and modern humans were already foraging and small-animal collecting.

"I think they were out-competed at the very end," says Jablonski. "Modern humans simply did it better, more nimbly."

She adds that modern humans may have had storage capabilities that Neandertal did not. There is evidence that modern humans did have the capacity to store food and water in the late Pleistocene. No evidence exists that Neandertal could store either.

Both Neandertal and modern humans suffered from the primate curses of single births widely spaced. For Neandertal, cultural adaptation was not sufficient to overcome and compete with modern humans, just as Paranthropus boisei could not compete with the likes of bush pigs and hyenas.

" Can we, today, control our cultural behavior to ensure our environmental success," says Jablonski. "Can we control growth and population density, or come up with new technology to overcome the problems we will face from the global climate change we have created?

"We clearly have the cultural ability to do either," says the Penn State researcher. "But both require forethought and planning to face the demographic and climate change. A degree of honesty, our species is not known for."

Email This Article

Related Links
Penn State
All About Human Beings and How We Got To Be Here

Getting On Your Nerves And Repairing Them
Bethesda MD (SPX) Feb 21, 2007
Here is some news that will certainly get on people's nerves: In a study to be published in the March 2007 issue of The FASEB Journal, scientists from East Carolina University report that a key molecular mechanism, RNA interference (RNAi), plays a role in the regeneration and repair of periphery nerves, which are the nerves located outside of the brain and spinal column.

.
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
  



  • Indonesia Delays Start Of Plan To Plug Mud Volcano
  • Bacteria Could Steady Buildings Against Earthquakes
  • Sending Out An SOS Russian Satellites Come To The Rescue
  • Indonesia To Use Concrete Balls To Plug "Mud Volcano"

  • Russia, Kyoto Protocol And Climate Change
  • In Chilly Washington Global Warming Gets New Airing
  • Blair Wants New Climate Change Deal Before Exit
  • US Offered Lucrative Lure Of Global Carbon Trading

  • Sandstorm Over The Mediterranean
  • 3D Upstart Eyes Google Earth With Helicopter
  • ESA Celebrates 15 Years Of Near-Real Time Data Delivery In Earth Observation
  • Gascom To Launch 4 Smotr Low-Orbit Remote Sensing Satellites

  • Tiny High-Frequency Cryocooler Is Cold And Efficient
  • Scientists Convert Heat To Power Using Organic Molecules
  • Wild Grass Could Hold Key To Clean Fuels Of The Future
  • For US Global Warming Is Now Hot

  • Moscow Region Authorities Dismiss Rumors Of Bird Flu Among Humans
  • Scientists On The Way To Sifting Out A Cure For HIV
  • End The Black AIDS Plague
  • British Company In Bird Flu Outbreak May Cut Jobs

  • St Petersburg Court Rejects Schoolgirl Suit Over Darwinism
  • Rat Like Senses A Whisker Away From Humans
  • Antarctic Warming To Reduce Animals At Base Of Ecosystem As Penguin Shift South
  • Researchers Untangle Nature Of Regressive Evolution In Cavefish

  • Sand Latest Irritant In Singapore Regional Ties
  • Ivory Coast Toxic Dump Victims Upset Over Pay Deal
  • EasyJet Chief Says Business Travellers Have Role In Saving Environment
  • Britain Launches Investigation Into Monsanto Toxic Waste

  • Team Takes First Deep Dive Into Molecular Machinery Of Human Brain
  • Birth Rate And Competition Were Major Reasons For Past Hominid Extinctions
  • Neuroscientists Explain Inner Workings Of Critical Pain Pathway
  • Human Ecological Footprint In 2015 And Amazonia Revealed

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement