Earth Science News  





. Do Plant Species Really Exist

Are plant species real or imaginary? Many botanists have argued grouping plants into species is merely an exercise of convenience. Image credit: Robert Czarny .
by Staff Writers
Bloomington IN (SPX) Mar 24, 2006
Notoriously "promiscuous" plants like oaks and dandelions have led some biologists to conclude plants cannot be divided into species the same way animals are.

That perception is wrong, say Indiana University Bloomington scientists in this week's Nature. Their analysis of 882 plant and animal species and 1,347 inter-species crossings -- the first large-scale comparison of species barriers in plants and animals -- showed that plant species are just as easily categorized as animal species.

The study also yielded a surprise. The hybrid offspring of different animal species are more likely to be fertile than the hybrid offspring of plant species.

"Not only are plants just as easily subdivided into species as animals when analyzed statistically, plants are more likely to be reproductively isolated due to hybrid sterility," said evolutionary biologist Loren Rieseberg, who led the study. "Most plant species are indeed 'real.' The problem has been that botanists have been way over-attracted to the plant species that readily hybridize and where the hybrids perpetuate themselves asexually. While it's true that dandelions and blackberries pose problems, these horror stories only make up 1 percent of the whole."

The scientists did find categorization problems with nearly half of the plant and animal species they surveyed.

Rieseberg and his co-authors, doctoral student Troy Wood and postdoctoral research associate Eric Baack, examined hundreds of peer-reviewed papers reporting the measurement of various plant and animal characteristics, or reporting on the success or failure of hybridization of plant and animal species with similar species. The scientists culled the papers for information, grouped and combined data for each given species, and then looked at how often characteristics clustered in accordance with named species.

The scientists found that while real, quantifiable clusters did exist in most groups of plants and animals, the one-to-one correspondence of species names and character clusters was quite low -- about 54 percent. One explanation for this, Rieseberg said, is that too many taxonomists are "splitters" -- they give too many species names to a single group of related organisms.

After analyzing the hybridization data, the scientists found that only 30 percent of the approximately 500 plant species they surveyed are able to produce fertile hybrids when mated with other species. By stark contrast, 61 percent of animal species surveyed are able to reproduce successfully with other species.

The hybridization of animal species is often portrayed as rare and strange, or else the result of human-forced matings, as is the case with ligers (lion-tiger hybrids) and mules (horse-ass hybrids). It is not common knowledge that many bird and fish species successfully hybridize in the wild. The scientists found that birds were most likely to produce fertile hybrids when crossed with other bird species. Ferns, of all things, were least likely to generate fertile hybrids.

Many of the hybridization papers that Rieseberg, Wood and Baack looked at reported crossings under laboratory conditions, and therefore the crossings may not accurately represent what happens in nature. For example, two species that can hybridize may not actually do so, perhaps because they exist on different continents or because they prefer to mate with members of their own species. For that reason, the percentages of plant and animal species that hybridize in the wild are likely to be lower than those reported by the scientists.

The Nature study is meant to address gaps in scientists' knowledge in two areas: the fundamental nature of species and the divisibility of plant and animal species using commonly accepted definitions of species. Debates in both areas began with the 1859 edition of Darwin's Origin of Species, and they have not yet been settled.

"These discussions should have been settled earlier, but no one bothered to summarize the relevant literature, perhaps because it is so vast," Rieseberg said.

Over the past 50 years, numerous scientific papers have been published in which species are categorized by statistical analysis of observable traits (i.e., numerical taxonomy) and/or by the ease with which species can be hybridized (i.e., breeding studies). "After going through all this literature, we realized someone just needed to compile and analyze it all," Rieseberg said.

The scientists decided to use the mass of data to see whether taxonomists were doing a good job, and whether cross-species mating in the plant kingdom is especially likely to be successful.

"The species concept debate has devolved from an empirical discussion into a philosophical one," Rieseberg said. "But this is fundamentally an empirical question. These data support the notion that species can be both units of evolution and products of evolution."

Rieseberg holds the Class of '54 Chair and is a distinguished professor of biology at IU Bloomington. Troy Wood and Eric Baack also contributed to the report. It was funded primarily by a Guggenheim Fellowship grant. Supplementary support came from the MacArthur Foundation, the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation.

Related Links
Indiana University Bloomington

Zookeepers In Indias Kolkata Mourn Death Of 255-year-old Tortoise
Kolkata, India (AFP) Mar 24, 2006
Zoo officials in Kolkata said Thursday a famed 255-year-old tortoise brought to the eastern Indian city during the rule of the British East India Company has died.

.
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
  



  • Fake Quake Tests US Readiness
  • Large Centrifuge Helps Researchers Mimic Effects Of Katrina On Levees
  • Louisiana Selects SGI For Storm Modeling And Visualization
  • Search For Katrina's Dead Stymied By Bureaucratic Wrangling

  • Governments Must Heed Warnings On Climate Change Now: UK Chief Scientist
  • Climate Change And The Rise Of Atmospheric Oxygen
  • Salt And Dust Help Unravel Past Climate Change
  • Manure Composting Reduces Greenhouse Gas Emissions

  • NASA Scientist Claims Warmer Ocean Waters Reducing Ice Worldwide
  • Space Tool Aids Fight For Clean Drinking Water
  • FluWrap: Deadly Strain Divides
  • Satellite Flood Mapping Service Strengthens Eastern France Civil Protection

  • Brown Backs 20-Bln-Dlr World Bank Energy Fund For Poor Nations
  • NREL Highlights Leading Utility Green Power Programs
  • Journal Of Industrial Ecology Focuses On Eco-Efficiency
  • USC, Rice To Develop Bacteria-Powered Fuel Cells

  • Researchers Seek Answers To Combat TB Epidemic
  • Warming Trend May Contribute To Malaria's Rise
  • Ebola Test Urgent Amid Globalism
  • Minor Mutations In Avian Flu Virus Increase Chances Of Human Infection

  • Junk DNA May Not Be So Junky After All
  • Single Gene Mutation Switches Fungus-Grass Symbiosis From Mutualistic To Antagonistic
  • Do Plant Species Really Exist
  • Zookeepers In India's Kolkata Mourn Death Of 255-year-old Tortoise

  • Moscow Targets Funds To Repair Nuclear Waste Plant
  • Hong Kong Pollution Leaves Tourists Choking
  • Reducing Soot Particles Is Associated With Longer Lives
  • Metabolites Of Pharmaceuticals Identified In Wastewater

  • Chimps, Like Us, Utilise Referential Gesturing
  • How Does The Brain Know What The Right Hand Is Doing
  • Pitt Researchers Find 'Switch' For Brain's Pleasure Pathway
  • Aggression-Related Gene Weakens Brain's Impulse Control Circuits

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement