East Lansing MI (SPX) Jul 07, 2010
Just about everyone agrees that sustainability - cutting energy use, reducing carbon emissions and, in general, keeping the Earth green - is a good thing. But why do we think that? Do we support sustainability for the right reasons?
These are among the questions that Michigan State University's Michael Nelson addresses in a paper published this month in the journal Bioscience titled "Sustainability: Virtuous or Vulgar?"
Specifically, Nelson and co-author John Vucetich of Michigan Technological University argue that the issue of ethics is a vital component in the teaching and research of sustainability, but one that is sorely lacking.
"This debate," they write, "has almost entirely neglected a fundamental dimension of sustainability - the ethical dimension. Lack of attention to the ethical dimension of sustainability is stifling progress toward sustainability."
Or, as Nelson puts it: "If we don't know where we're going, we won't know when we get there."
Nelson said that from the educational perspective, it's important that all aspects of sustainability are covered.
"Everything we do sends messages to our students," he said. "We see our students as people who will go out and do important things in this world. It's important how we nurture that."
The ultimate question, the authors say, is this: "Do we care about ecosystem health because ecosystems are intrinsically valuable, or do we care about ecosystem health because it serves human interests?"
While a question such as this is difficult to answer, Nelson said that "we are unlikely to achieve sustainability without knowing what it means."
In their paper, Nelson and Vucetich consider the most widely appreciated definitions of sustainability, which indicate at least roughly that sustainability is "meeting human needs in a socially just manner without depriving ecosystems of their health."
While the definition seems quite specific, it could mean anything from "exploit as much as desired without infringing on the future ability to exploit as much as desired" to "exploit as little as necessary to maintain a meaningful life."
"From a single definition rises two wildly disparate views of a sustainable world," said Vucetich. "Handling these disparate views is the inescapable ethical crisis of sustainability."
"The crisis results from not knowing what we mean by value-laden terms like 'ecosystem health' and 'human needs,'" Nelson said. "In other words, is ecosystem health defined by its ability to meet human needs only, or does ecosystem health define the limits of human need?"
Nelson is an associate professor with appointments in MSU's Lyman Briggs College and the departments of Fisheries and Wildlife and Philosophy. Vucetich is an assistant professor in MTU's School of Forest Resources and Environmental Science.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Michigan State University's
Dirt, rocks and all the stuff we stand on firmly
Delivering Cost-Effective Biodiversity Protection
Victoria, Australia (SPX) Jul 02, 2010
A more flexible approach to the expansion of protected area systems could ultimately protect much more biodiversity for the same budget according to a new paper in the scientific journal Nature. Lead author Dr Richard Fuller of the CSIRO Climate Adaptation Flagship and The University of Queensland said that without spending extra money "we could dramatically improve the performance of prot ... read more
US government launches new website on Gulf oil spill|
Thousands demonstrate over Italy quake help
Peru declares emergency after mining dam collapse
24 dead in China shuttle bus fire: govt
Wake up, check Facebook
Apple to issue patch for iPhone 4 antenna woes
Apple hit with lawsuit over iPhone 4 antenna woes
New Multi-Year LTA With EADS Astrium To Power All GEO Satellites
Cleaner Water Mitigates Climate Change Effects On Florida Keys Coral Reefs
La Nina likely to develop in coming months: UN weather body
More Fish Than Thought May Thrive In The Ocean's Depths
Oil spills boost arsenic levels in ocean: study
Arctic Climate May Be More Sensitive To Warming Than Thought
US scientist in race to learn from Indonesia's dying glacier
China sets sail for the Arctic
Answer To What Ended The Last Ice Age May Be Blowing In The Winds
China's AgBank raises 10 billion dollars in Shanghai IPO
AgBank prices Hong Kong IPO lower than expected
Salmon In Hot Water
US Approach To Farming Should Change To Meet New Challenges
Romanians brace for Danube flood peak
Romania issues flooding red alert on the Danube
Weakened Alex leaves seven dead in northeast Mexico
Romania flood death toll climbs to 25: official
Religious intolerance threatens Nigerian democracy: Jonathan
Chinese-built hospital risks collapse in Angola: state radio
U.N. pullback likely to worsen Congo wars
Foreign agents in shooting of Rwandan general: S.Africa
U.S. government challenges Ariz. law
Tibetan Adaptation To Altitude Took Less Than 3,000 Years
A Butterfly Effect In The Brain
China To Hit 1.4 Billion As Medvedev Fears Falling Population In Russia's East
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|