Earth Science News  





. Military Matters: Shooting up schools

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by William S. Lind
Washington (UPI) Feb 27, 2008
Between Feb. 8 and Feb. 14, four American schools suffered attacks by lone gunmen. The most recent, at Northern Illinois University on Feb. 14, saw five killed, plus the gunman, and 16 wounded. Similar attacks have occurred elsewhere, including shopping malls.

Is this war? I don't think so. Some proponents of "Fifth Generation War," which they define as actions by "super-empowered individuals," may disagree. But these incidents lack an ingredient I think necessary to war's definition, namely purpose. In Fourth Generation war, the purpose of warlike acts reaches beyond the state and politics, but actions, including massacres of civilians, are still purposeful. They serve an agenda that reaches beyond individual emotions, an agenda others can and do share and fight for. In contrast, the mental and emotional states that motivate lone gunmen are knowable to them alone.

The whole "Fifth Generation" thesis is faulty, in any case. However small the units that fight wars may become, down to the "super-empowered individual," that shrinkage alone is not enough to mark a new generation.

Generational changes are dialectically qualitative changes, and those are rare. Normally, a dialectically qualitative change only occurs after time has brought many dialectically quantitative changes, such as a downward progression in the size of units that can fight. In effect, quantitative changes have to pool behind a generational dam until they form so vast a reservoir that their combined pressure breaks through in a torrent. I expect it will take at least a century for the Fourth Generation to play itself out. A Fifth Generation will not be in sight, except as a mirage, in our lifetimes.

This is not to say that the lone-gunman phenomenon and its increasing frequency are wholly unrelated to Fourth Generation war -- 4GW. They have some common origins, I think.

At the core of 4GW lies a crisis of legitimacy of the state. A development that contributes to the state's crisis of legitimacy is the disintegration of community -- Gemeinschaft. Since the beginning of the Industrial Revolution and the rise of the powerful, highly intrusive state, community has increasingly been displaced by society -- Gesellschaft -- where most relationships between people are merely functional.

That progression has now gone so far that never before in human history have so many people lived isolated lives. I sometimes visualize a conversation between a Modern man and a Medieval man, where the proud Modern says, "You poor man! It must have been terrible living without air conditioning, automobiles, washing machines and hot showers." The Medieval man replies, "You poor man! It must have been terrible living so alone."

Isolation and the alienation, anomie and rage that proceed from it fuel both lone gunmen and a broad sense of detachment from the state. Why give loyalty to the state if the society it governs offers nothing but alienation? In turn, alternatives to the state, such as gangs, offer alternatives to isolation as well.

The commonality does not stop here. Increasingly, people who are cut off from other real people fill the void with virtual people. They spend their lives immersed in television, video games, the Internet and so on. As Dave Grossman has demonstrated, those technologies can do an excellent job of turning loners into killers, both by overcoming their inhibitions to killing and by giving them refined shooter skills.

The same technologies spread alternate loyalties, such as al-Qaida, Deep Green environmentalism -- which has spawned numerous acts of terror, both here and in Britain -- and a variety of other virtual worlds.

In sum, the decline of the state and the disintegration of community march on together. So, through the video screen, do the rise of alternate loyalties and the generation of lone gunmen. Both are part of the end of the Modern Age, facilitated and accelerated by technologies that are Modernity's penultimate achievements.

As the Spanish philosopher Jose Ortega y Gasset warned, civilized men are being replaced by technologically competent barbarians. Barbarians "act out" their emotions by killing, and they give their allegiance to chieftains, not states. Lone gunmen are not carrying on war, but the phenomena that create them also feed the Fourth Generation. The calamitous 21st century will give us more of both.

-- (William S. Lind, expressing his own personal opinion, is director of the Center for Cultural Conservatism at the Free Congress Foundation.)

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
All About Human Beings and How We Got To Be Here




Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison

Newsletters :: SpaceDaily Express :: SpaceWar Express :: TerraDaily Express :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News
Large Portion Of Brain Switches Off And Lets Creativity Flow In Jazz Improvisations
Washington DC (SPX) Feb 27, 2008
When John Coltrane was expanding the boundaries of the well-known song "My Favorite Things" at the Village Vanguard in May 1966, no one could have known what inspired him to take the musical turns he took. But imaging researchers may now have a better picture of how the brain was helping to carry him there.

.
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
  



  • Indonesian city braces for disaster with little more than hope
  • Death toll from China snow storms hits 129: report
  • Kenya, UN warn crisis risks incubating new AIDS infections
  • Philippine floods and landslides toll rises to 26: officials

  • Monsoon intensity driven by Earth's orbit: study
  • Why Juniper Trees Can Live On Less Water
  • Wind variations may spur climate change
  • Voyage To Southern Ocean Aims To Study Air-Sea Fluxes Of Greenhouse Gases

  • Falcon Investigates Pollution From The Dakar Metropolis Into Desert Dust Layers
  • NASA Extends Mission For Ball Aerospace-Built ICESat
  • CIRA Scientist Among Authors Of Book Celebrating 50 Years Of Earth Observations From Space
  • Indonesia To Develop New EO Satellite

  • Exxon Valdez: oil company tells top court captain was to blame
  • Sofitel Hotels Become First Wind Powered Hotel Chain In The US
  • Analysis: Cuban oil production down
  • ADA-ES Plans To Provide Activated Carbon To The Power Industry

  • WHO plays down bird flu threat in China after three human deaths
  • Death of woman confirmed bird flu related: China health ministry
  • Yellow fever outbreak reported in Paraguay
  • Woman dies in southern China, tested positive for bird flu

  • Invasion Of The Cane Toads
  • MBL Creates Portal for Online Macroscope To Explore Life's Mysteries
  • Life May Have Begun In The Hot Or The Cold
  • Two Oxygenation Events In Ancient Oceans Sparked Spread Of Complex Life

  • Creation Of A New Material Capable Of Eliminating Pollutants Generated By The Hydrocarbon Industry
  • US DoE And Foundation Capital Partner To Commercialize Groundbreaking New Clean Energy Technologies
  • US DoE Funds Four Projects Developing Cost-Effective Enzymes For Advanced Biofuels
  • China's listed firms forced to submit environmental data: report

  • Delving Into The Deepest Recesses Of Human Brain
  • Military Matters: Shooting up schools
  • From Delicious To Death: Understanding Taste
  • Large Portion Of Brain Switches Off And Lets Creativity Flow In Jazz Improvisations

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement