Earth Science News  





. Scientists Debate The Accuracy Of Al Gore's Documentary An Inconvenient Truth

Eric Steig from Washington University states that the film gets the fundamental science right. The minor factual errors do not undermine the main message of the film, which explains the theory that increasing carbon dioxide causes a warming tendency in the lower atmosphere.
by Staff Writers
Washington DC (SPX) Apr 15, 2008
There is no question that Al Gore's 2006 documentary An Inconvenient Truth is a powerful example of how scientific knowledge can be communicated to a lay audience. What is up for debate is whether it accurately presents the scientific argument that global warming is caused by human activities. Climate change experts express their opinions on the scientific validity of the film's claims in articles just published online in Springer's journal, GeoJournal.

An Inconvenient Truth is about Al Gore's campaign to educate citizens about global warming and inspire them to take action. The papers in GeoJournal agree that it does an excellent job of raising public awareness of man-made global warming and explains why increased atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases lead to warming.

They also agree that its main weakness is that it tries to use individual extreme events, such as Hurricane Katrina, to prove the existence of global warming.

In the first opinion piece, Eric Steig from Washington University states that the film gets the fundamental science right. The minor factual errors do not undermine the main message of the film, which explains the theory that increasing carbon dioxide causes a warming tendency in the lower atmosphere.

John Nielsen-Gammon from Texas A and M University also agrees that the main scientific argument presented in the movie is for the most part consistent with the weight of scientific evidence. He comments that unfortunately, it neglects all information that can be gained from computer models, and instead relies entirely on past and current observational evidence. This increases the film's emotional impact but weakens the scientific argument.

David Legates from the University of Delaware addresses assertions about trends in precipitation, floods, droughts and storms in particular. He concludes that there are significant errors in the film, owing to alarmism and exaggeration, which give a false impression of both the current state of climate change and that the science is settled.

In another paper, Roy Spencer from the University of Alabama in Huntsville also discredits the scientific validity of the documentary. In his view, the film's main omission is that while humans are almost certainly responsible for global warming, there are other natural causes of climate variability which the film does not address. In his opinion, the "real inconvenient truth is that science has no idea how much of recent warming is natural versus the result of human activities".

After providing a succinct summary of the state of climate change science, Gerald North from Texas A and M University concludes the debate by stating that although there are some inaccuracies and exaggerations in the film, on the whole it represents mainstream scientific views on global warming.

Steven Quiring, also from Texas A and M University and author of the issue's introduction, comes to the conclusion that whether scientists like it or not, An Inconvenient Truth has had a much greater impact on public opinion and public awareness of global climate change than any scientific paper or report.

Community
Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Climate Science News - Modeling, Mitigation Adaptation




Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison

Newsletters :: SpaceDaily Express :: SpaceWar Express :: TerraDaily Express :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News
China surpasses US as top carbon polluter: study
Los Angeles (AFP) April 15, 2008
China has already surpassed the United States as the world's largest carbon polluter, the authors of a California study said Tuesday.

.
Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
  



  • Big Tokyo quake would cause human gridlock: study
  • Disasters In Small Communities: Researchers Discuss How To Help
  • Raytheon Develops Advanced Concrete Breaking Technology For Urban Search And Rescue
  • Floods, cyclones, devastate southern Africa: UN

  • Bush 'can't support' climate bills in Congress: White House
  • Bush to give speech on climate change: White House
  • China surpasses US as top carbon polluter: study
  • Scientists Debate The Accuracy Of Al Gore's Documentary An Inconvenient Truth

  • Contract Signed For ESA's Sentinel-3 Earth Observation Satellite
  • General Dynamics AIS Completes Testing For GeoEye's Next-Gen Earth Imaging Satellite
  • Harris Ground System For GOES-R Weather Satellite On Display
  • Project Explores Using NASA Earth Science Data For Enhanced Utility Load Forecasting

  • Nigeria says China, India to build it oil refineries
  • British energy giant BP says China has bought 1.0-percent stake
  • Methane Generated From Sioux Falls Regional Landfill To Provide Energy For POET Ethanol Plant
  • New Small Scale Ethanol Plants Using Highly Efficient Waste

  • China rejects human-to-human bird flu report
  • Human infects human with bird flu in China: study
  • Alligator Blood And Mud Help Fight Superbugs
  • Bird flu breaks out at Tibet poultry farm: China

  • Ancient Dragon Has Space-Age Skull
  • Insects Evolved Radically Different Strategy To Smell
  • Plants deserve respect, Swiss committee says
  • Researchers Develop New Conservation Map For Biodiversity Hotspot

  • 'Bin brother' tagging Australian rubbish
  • China mine spill blackens river with toxic slurry
  • Ships dumping waste in Mediterranean illegal as of 2009: UN
  • Russian mayor urges closure of own town: report

  • Unconscious Decisions In The Brain
  • Plan Brokered By UCLA, USC Archaeologists Would Remove Roadblock To Mideast Peace
  • Scientists Find A Fingerprint Of Evolution Across The Human Genome
  • The Voyage To America

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement