Washington DC (SPX) Mar 30, 2011
When influenza pandemics arrive, the specter of disease spread through person-to-person contact can mean that schools close, hand sanitizer sales rise, and travellers stay home. But is severing social and business interactions with our neighbors really better than taking a chance on getting sick?
"Infectious disease can mean making trade-offs between the risks and rewards of meeting others," says Eli Fenichel, an Arizona State University scientist. "It's critical that we more clearly understand the role that human decisions play in transmitting disease."
Fenichel, a professor in ASU's School of Life Sciences and lead author, is one of five ASU scientists in a transdisciplinary working group that has developed a better model for understanding the role of adaptive human behavior in the spread of disease. The group's work appears in this week's online edition of the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS).
Mathematical models are commonly used to help to forecast diseases and to develop science-based approaches to improve public health.
However, while behavioral change has been a primary human defense against disease since the plagues of the Middle Ages, behavior change has only recently caught the attention of epidemiologists charged with forecasting disease outbreaks and providing scientific guidance on public health policy.
In this PNAS study, the authors point out that traditional epidemiological models assume that peoples' behaviors remain constant when faced with disease risk, and don't allow accurate assessment of public health decisions that encourage behavior change or "social distancing" policies.
In an outbreak of severe disease, epidemiologists rely on a measurement called "R0" or R-naught to quantify the transmissibility of a virus or other pathogen in a population and to determine vaccination or treatment programs. According to the authors' model, R0 alone is an unreliable measurement when disease risk alters human behavior.
Fenichel says that people place different values on interpersonal relations based on a variety of considerations, and how they act will depend on that value.
"Behavioral restrictions can function as a tax on interactions and need to be considered," Fenichel says. "For example, a suggestion by health officials to 'fist bump,' rather than shake hands is good in informal situations. But if you have a job interview that behavior might be costly."
Further, notes coauthor Carlos Castillo-Chavez: "Different people from different cultures respond differently to disease threats. As citizens of a global village, we must better understand the collective behavior and individual decisions people make when faced by the risks of disease." Castillo-Chavez is a professor in the School of Human Evolution and Social Change in ASU's College of Liberal Arts and Sciences.
The new model accounts for tradeoffs that people make when weighing the risk of exposure to illness versus the benefits of interacting with other people. The benefit of good health is only one part of an overall index of satisfaction or "utility" or "wellbeing." This is especially true when most people don't expect any permanent side-effects from illness.
How does this play out at a societal level? In a simulated outbreak, a small increase in the price of interpersonal contact lowers the peak prevalence of the disease slightly. Slightly fewer people become infected and social utility is increased.
Further increase in the price of contact, which causes individuals to make even fewer contacts, can prevent even more people from getting sick; however, this can decrease the overall benefits to society.
"Our model allows us to include behavior and shows how behavioral incentives can shape the dynamics of a disease," says Fenichel.
The researchers hope that their modeling framework helps in the creation of more effective and lower cost public health responses to infectious disease.
"This work should offer a novel approach to the challenging task of capturing dynamic population behavior in infectious disease transmission models," says Gerardo Chowell, a mathematical epidemiologist in ASU's School of Human Evolution and Social Change and researcher with the Fogarty International Center at the National Institutes of Health.
The research for the PNAS publication was conducted by an interdisciplinary group of epidemiologists, economists, ecologists, and mathematicians - all part of the SPIDER (Synthesizing and Predicting Infectious Disease While Accounting for Endogenous Risk) Working Group at the National Institute for Mathematical and Biological Synthesis (NIMBioS).
"This work points out the importance of including individual behaviors, based upon personal economic decisions, in analyzing social responses to diseases," says NIMBioS Director Louis Gross.
"The SPIDER Working Group's new mathematical framework that incorporates feedback responses between individuals and their perception of disease and economic risk is a highly useful method to evaluate public health policies with a level of generality that is not readily available from more complex computational models."
The other members of the SPIDER Working Group who co-authored the paper are M. Graziano Ceddia of University of Reading, Paula Andrea Gonzalez Parra of The University of Texas at El Paso, Graham J. Hickling of NIMBioS and the Center for Wildlife Health at the University of Tennessee, Garth Holloway of University of Reading, Richard D. Horan of Michigan State University, Benjamin Morin of Arizona State University, Charles Perrings of Arizona State University, Michael Springborn of University of California, Davis, Leticia Velazquez of The University of Texas at El Paso, and Cristina Villalobos of the University of Texas-Pan American.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
National Institute for Mathematical and Biological Synthesis (NIMBioS)
Epidemics on Earth - Bird Flu, HIV/AIDS, Ebola
Mexican governor says new H1N1 outbreak came from US
Ciudad Juarez, Mexico (AFP) March 28, 2011
A new outbreak of H1N1 in northern Mexico, which left four dead in the past week, originated in the southern United States, the Chihuahua state governor said Monday. "It has been confirmed that the woman who died in Chihuahua was on a trip from the (US) state of Texas. Also, those infected in Ciudad Juarez were all linked to trips to the United States or contact with US citizens," Cesar Duar ... read more
Japan's atomic plant neighbours mull leaving homes|
Insurance market Lloyd's 2010 profits tumble
Japan mulls draping fabric over reactors: report
Cost of disasters tripled in 2010: Swiss Re
UN atomic watchdog raises alarm over Japan evacuations
Cancer Risk Of Backscatter Airport Scanners Is Low
IAEA worried about radiation in Japan village
Taiwan fair to see 100 tablet launches: organisers
Police, protesters clash over China dam
First Broad-Scale Maps Of Life On The Sea-Shelf
Dolphin toll from BP oil spill far higher: study
ADB and OPEC Fund aid Sierra Leone water project
Antarctic Icebergs Play A Previously Unknown Role In Global Carbon Cycle, Climate
Study Sheds Light On How Heat Is Transported To Greenland Glaciers
Large-Scale Assessment Of Arctic Ocean Show Significant Increase In Freshwater Content
Study: 2011 arctic ice extent is down
Good wheat harvest expected in Pakistan, despite floods
Local, Diversified Food Production Needed To Curb Food Price Crisis
Ants And Termites Boost Dryland Wheat Yields
Japan urges trading partners not to overreact on food safety
Thai floods kill 15 dead, thousands stranded
Climate Modelling And The Rain
Deep-Sea Volcanoes Explode
Namibia declares state of emergency after flooding
Africa turns to cellphones for better health
A New Scramble For African Riches - Its Consumers
Sudan president heads to Qatar amid Darfur violence
Burkina Faso soldiers freed from prison after protests
Research Proves No 2 Of Us Are Alike, Even Identical Twins
Researchers Detail How Neurons Decide How To Transmit Information
Rare gene defect affects both pain, smell
A New Evolutionary History Of Primates
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|