Yaounde, Cameroon (SPX) Nov 22, 2010
A new study finds a lack of transparency and corruption are reducing the impact of an initiative in Cameroon that channels a portion of national timber levies to rural forest communities. The study highlights the challenges of using a climate change pact to do something similar in forested regions around the world.
In an article published in the peer-reviewed journal International Forestry Review, scientists at the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) examined how revenues from a tax paid by logging companies in Cameroon, known as an Area Fee (AF), are distributed to local councils to reduce rural poverty and stimulate local economic growth.
Paolo Omar Cerutti, the study's lead author, said the AF's impact is diluted by a murky and unreliable system for distributing revenues to local communities and a failure to discourage embezzlement and mismanagement in areas that receive funds. CIFOR also found evidence that at least a portion of the AF money is being used for programs that should be supported by central government appropriations.
"Cameroon has established a potentially transformative mechanism for sharing timber revenues with poor communities but we found the AF distributions, while a very promising concept, are not yet realizing their full potential," Cerutti said.
"But problems can be solved," he added, "and they can be enormously instructive for establishing equitable mechanisms for the distribution of REDD+ funds."
REDD+ is shorthand for "reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation" The plus is a recent add-on, which represents conserving and enhancing forest carbon stocks, as well as the sustainable management of forests.
It is the term used within international climate change talks for a proposed agreement that would establish a system to reward developing countries for not cutting down their forests because of the carbon stored in them. If successful, REDD+ could generate billions of dollars for some of the world's poorest communities.
The CIFOR study highlights the challenges that could arise in trying to fairly distribute REDD+ funds, and in seeing the money invested to improve the livelihoods of forest communities.
The law in Cameroon stipulates that local communities-mainly through their local governing councils and mayors-should receive 50 percent of AF taxes levied on logging companies. The sums are large, given that from 2000 to 2008, the national government collected euros 20 million (US$27.3 million) in AF taxes annually, which means euros 10 million (US$13,7 million) should have been available for local use.
According to CIFOR, each of these variables are subject to change and, furthermore, they are controlled by different ministries "who do not consult with each other."
As a result there are frequent instances in which communities don't get the funds they are expecting. Given the lack of coordination and data sharing among ministries, it is difficult to determine whether allocations are fair or not.
In addition, there is widespread suspicion that some of the AF money is mismanaged and even embezzled by local officials. For example, an assessment of eight councils that received a large amount of AF money found that 22 percent of annual expenditures were "hardly traceable intangible expenses" that appeared to "depend on the discretionary power of the mayors."
The mayors must stand for election, but CIFOR found that the even when voters widely suspect them of diverting AF money for personal use, most manage to retain power by manipulating local councils and party power structures.
Other complications also emerged. For example, mayors are sometimes at risk of becoming the "political scapegoat" for funding shortfalls created by the national government's distribution system.
The CIFOR article notes that in 2009, the government's AF was cut in half to soften the impact of the financial crisis on logging companies. That decision meant less money for local councils.
Meanwhile, local councils routinely invest the AF money in basic infrastructure projects that should normally be funded by national appropriations, encouraging the idea that AF money is simply "substitute revenue" for programs that should be supported by the central government.
"Clearly, a functional system for allocating forest revenues-whether we are talking about Cameroon's Area Fund or, on a much larger scale, REDD+ funds-needs to be simple, equitable and transparent," Cerutti said.
"But improving the distribution component is not enough," he added. "The experience in Cameroon also highlights the importance of independent oversight to monitor, detect and sanction embezzlement or mismanagement at the local level."
Cerutti also said it is critical that such programs don't end up as an excuse for governments to renege on their obligations, thus negating the potential for the new money to reduce poverty.
"If the Area Fee money, or REDD+ money becomes a substitution for funds that the central government should be providing, then we are right back where we started," he said.
The study was published in the International Forestry Review in June 2010. For more information, see here.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Center for International Forestry Research
Forests Climate Change
Forestry News - Global and Local News, Science and Application
'Forgotten' forests store carbon
Washington (UPI) Nov 19, 2010
While the deforestation of tropical rainforests is seen as a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, the impact of cool-weather rainforests tends to be overlooked when addressing climate change, a panel of scientists said. These "forgotten" rainforests store more carbon per acre than tropical rainforests, the scientists said in Washington Wednesday while introducing "Temperate an ... read more
Gates backs crisis cells to aid Latin America in disasters|
US Socially Responsible Investing Thrives In Recession
Chinese worker saved after 80 hours in underwater pipe
Italian quake victims denounce reconstruction pace
Thales announces venture for Chinese in-flight systems
News Corp. set to unveil iPad newspaper, 'The Daily'
FASTRAC Team Ready To Enjoy Launch
Amazon lets gift-givers send Kindle books by email
More than a million Atlantic sharks killed yearly: study
Busy Microbial World Discovered In Deepest Ocean Crust Ever Explored
Fall Bonefish Census Sounds Warning Bell That Warrants Careful Future Monitoring
Indonesia declares protected zone to save coral reefs
Operation IceBridge Completes Another Successful Antarctic Campaign
Delayed ice threatening Canada polar bears
As Arctic Temperatures Rise, Tundra Fires Increase
Drumlin Field Provides Answers About Glaciation And Climate
China milk campaigner 'forced to sack lawyers': rights group
Gene Find Could Lead To Healthier Food And Better Biofuel
Melamine-tainted drinks emerge again in China: report
New Disease-Resistant Food Crops In Prospect
Safe water out of reach for poor Haitians
Indonesia volcano death toll passes 300
Villagers flee as Philippine volcano shoots ash
Danger zone reduced as Indonesian eruption weakens
I. Coast army deploys in north ahead of election
Madagascan army crushes three-day mutiny
China, Angola sign agreements as vice-president Xi visits
Swazi life expectancy halved by AIDS, TB: health charity
Study Reveals Neural Basis Of Rapid Brain Adaptation
Human Children Outpaced Neanderthals By Slowing Down
Paraguay nixes British expedition to remote tribal region
Origin Of Cells Associated With Nerve Repair Discovered
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|