Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Earth Science News .

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

Canadian Farmer On Global Crusade Against GM Seeds

Canadian farmer Percy Schmeiser poses for a photograph in New Delhi, 06 February 2007. When Monsanto decided to take Canadian farmer Percy Schmeiser to court for using its seeds, the US biotech giant didn't know it was creating a folk hero for the anti-GM crop movement. Since losing a series of court battles with Monsanto, Schmeiser has been travelling the world on a crusade against genetically modified (GM) crops and patenting seeds, speaking to environment groups and public gatherings. Photo courtesy AFP.

Monsanto film gets second life, but over fear of GMs or of censorship?
Paris (AFP) Feb 8 - A French documentary on GMs watched by around 400,000 viewers on pay-TV when first screened has won more than a million new viewers on the net over the past 10 days, but it remains unclear whether fears over the environment or rumours of censorship are feeding the new interest. Paul Moreira's "Are GM's dangerous for health?", which takes a critical look at tests carried out by US giant Monsanto on genetically modified (GM) crops, was first screened on France's Canal Plus channel in November 2005 and seen by less than half a million people.

But as of Thursday morning, Google video site had registered 1,146,742 connections "When it was first put on line in November there were 300 connections a day, now there are 300,000", said Regis Castellani, who has a link to the film on his site on ethical issues and multinationals ( He told AFP that reports the documentary had been censored had fuelled soaring interest "like a summer forest fire."

But film-maker Moreira denied that Canal Plus had deleted a sequence from the original film. "All you have to do is to mention censorship to set off Internet paranoia," he said. That view was not shared by one of the candidates running for the upcoming French elections, environmentalist Corinne Lepage. She said the documentary's new popularity illustrated France's "very real concern" over GMs.

by Penny MacRae
New Delhi (AFP) Feb 8, 2007
When Monsanto decided to take Canadian farmer Percy Schmeiser to court for using its seeds, the US biotech giant didn't know it was creating a folk hero for the anti-GM crop movement. Since losing a series of court battles with Monsanto, Schmeiser has been travelling the world on a crusade against genetically modified (GM) crops and patenting seeds, speaking to environment groups and public gatherings.

"I've always campaigned on the right of a farmer to save and use his own seed," Schmeiser told an anti-GM conference of environmentalists and farmers in the Indian capital this week.

GM crops have become a hot-button issue in India with some seeing it as key to boosting food output while others fear the long-term impact of such a step. "No one should have the right to patent life, it's a mad science," said the 76-year-old Schmeiser.

Schmeiser's run-in with Monsanto began in 1998 when the company told him he had infringed a patent for a genetically modified strain of canola it found growing on his farm in Saskatchewan.

In the landmark "seed piracy" case which went all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada and drew global attention, he claimed the canola seeds were carried by the wind into his field.

In a narrow 5-4 decision in 2004, the court gave no opinion on how the seeds got onto his land. But it did rule Schmeiser knew what the seeds were when he saved some from his harvest and planted a bigger crop the next year.

He had insisted he did not know the seeds were those Monsanto had patented. The former mayor of the small Saskatchewan town of Bruno maintains he had the right to plant the seeds as "farmers down through history" have had the right to plant their own seeds.

The judges decided if the plant contained a patented gene, the patent-holder had rights over the use of the plant. It was the first time a top court of any nation had ruled on patent issues involving seed genes.

Monsanto, which says it must strictly police its "no replant" policy to recoup huge sums spent developing seeds and to provide ever more productive ones, hailed the ruling.

It said it set a "world standard in intellectual property protection."

Despite the loss, Schmeiser has not given up fighting against GM crops and seed patents.

Schmeiser, whose travel bills are often paid by groups opposed to bio-engineering, says he plans on being a thorn in the GM industry's side as long as he is physically able.

The farmer is off to Japan next month to attend a Greenpeace event.

"If you believe in something you have got to give it all you can which is what I am doing," he told AFP in an interview.

Today genetically altered seeds can be found in hundreds of crop varieties sold under licence. Just a few US and European agricultural companies control much of the world's certified food seed supply and Monsanto is the largest.

Many farmers report increased yields and lower use of pesticides with GM crops. GM companies also say GM seeds can mean nutritionally enhanced food to better feed the world's hungry.

India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said late last year the country needed to "strike a balance between using the potential of biotechnical to meet the requirements of hungry people, while addressing ethical concerns about interferring with nature."

India has so far not allowed cultivation of GM crops for human consumption and cotton is the only such crop grown commercially.

GM critics say there is not enough research to determine that such GM crops are safe for people to eat or for the environment.

"Once you introduce a life form into the environment there's no calling it back. You can't contain the wind, you can't contain the seed movement. You can't contain it and it will spread, says Schmeiser, a third-generation farmer.

"You can't stop birds and bees from moving seed and this means organic and farmers using GM crops can't coexist," Schmeiser said.

Schmeiser's biggest worry now is a package of genes known as the "terminator." When introduced into seeds, the genes make sure the ensuing plants can never produce seeds of their own -- helping solve the seed piracy problem.

However, critics say this would make poor farmers around the world dependent on companies to provide them with the seeds each year. There is a UN moratorium at present blocking commercialisation of terminator seeds.

"It is the greatest assault on life we have ever seen on the face of the planet - seeds that are sterile," Schmeiser said.

Source: Agence France-Presse

Related Links
The latest farming technology and science news

New Management Tool For East Australian Graziers
Canberra, Australia (SPX) Feb 08, 2007
CSIRO has just released a new real-time information tool to help graziers in eastern Australia better cope with the impact of climate variations on pasture production. Primary producers from Rockhampton in Queensland across to Ceduna in South Australia and down to Tasmania can now access newly released satellite pasture growth data from the Pastures from Space website here.

  • Call To Move Indonesian Capital After Deadly Floods
  • Catastrophe Bonds A Market Answer To Hail Or High Water
  • UN Warns Of Natural Disasters Linked To Global Warming
  • Ireland Launches Rapid Response Unit For International Crises

  • Study Shows Largest North America Climate Change In 65 Million Years
  • From Greenhouse To Icehouse: New Clues On Ancient Climate Shift
  • White House Issues Rare Letter Defending Record On Warming
  • Climate Change Has Driven World To 'Critical Stage'

  • Gascom To Launch 4 Smotr Low-Orbit Remote Sensing Satellites
  • Google Earth To Blur Key India Sites
  • GeoEye Makes Final Debt Payment For The Purchase Of Space Imaging
  • Canada And US Launch Satellite Mapping Project Of North America

  • Russia-India Energy Dialogue Traditions And Prospects
  • Safeway Joins California Climate Action Registry
  • Scientists Develop Portable Generator That Turns Trash Into Electricity
  • Russia To Consider Idea Of International Gas OPEC

  • US Overdue For Bird Flu Experts Warn
  • EU Confirms Virulent H5N1 Bird Flu Found At British Poultry Farm
  • Scientists Reveal A Virus' Secret Weapon
  • Study Uncovers A Lethal Secret Of 1918 Influenza Virus

  • Adaptation To Global Climate Change Is An Essential Response To A Warming Planet
  • Electric Fish Shed Light On Ways The Brain Directs Movement
  • Return Of Wolves To Britain Would Be Howling Success
  • Investigating The Invisible Life In Our Environment

  • Facing Jail US Mining Boss Says Pollution Trial A Sham
  • Cleanup Of SLAC Cooling Tower Leak Complete Workers Investigating Cause
  • EU To Propose Laws To Fight 'Green Crimes'
  • Government Selling House Dust For $450 A Unit

  • Risk Of Extinction Accelerated Due To Interacting Human Threats
  • Human Ecological Footprint In 2015 And Amazonia Revealed
  • Selectivity Is Ultimate Aphrodisiac
  • Carnegie Mellon Student Develops Mood-Sharing Gadget To Help Computer Users Express Their Feelings

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement