. Earth Science News .

Differing dangers at sea
by Silje Stangeland
Stavanger, Norway (SPX) Jan 10, 2012

File image.

The probability of being killed at work is 25 times higher for a coastal fisherman than for an offshore worker, according to a study from the UiS. Seafarers also run a high risk of accidents.

Fifteen people died on vessels registered in Norway during 2010, figures from the Norwegian Maritime Directorate (NMD) show. Eight of these were fishermen.

Although these statistics show that the number of work accidents went down in 2009-10, the total has remained at a high and stable level for many decades.

The number of accidents in maritime transport has moreover increased since 2000, with a growing number of vessels sinking, going aground or being involved in collisions.

"When fishing smacks sink, the effect is usually felt by small coastal communities where high risk has been accepted for generations," says Preben Lindoe.

"Such individual accidents at sea fail to attract media attention or to generate any public debate on safety."

As professor at the University of Stavanger (UiS), he questions why Norwegians accept such big losses in fishing and shipping, with many accidents on merchant ships also ignored or forgotten.

Prof Lindoe notes, for example, that more than 90 bulk carriers of a certain type have been wrecked or sunk over a period of 15 years, during which time over 600 seafarers have died.

He and fellow UiS professors Ole Andreas Engen and Odd Einar Olsen have recently published an article in Safety Science on Responses to accidents in different industrial sectors.

Looking at the progress made by safety efforts in offshore, fishing and some shipping activities, their research has identified major differences.

That includes the much greater likelihood of fishermen being killed compared with offshore workers over the past 15 years, Prof Lindoe notes.

He sees a clear connection between the differing levels of attention paid to safety in these three sectors and the notice this issue has attracted from outside.

"A concentration of public awareness on only certain industries reveals some paradoxical aspects of our perception and handling of safety in society."

This view is backed by Prof Engen: "It's easier to adopt regulations under pressure from government and unions, for instance, in industries where risk and dangers are visible and attract great public concern. The oil sector is a case in point."

He notes that the figures for injuries and accidents on Norwegian offshore facilities have declined sharply since the 1980s.

"Several major accidents, such as the Ekofisk Bravo blowout in 1977 and the Alexander L Kielland disaster in 1980, were a wake-up call to oil companies, government, and the general public. The gas leak on Snorre A in 2004 served as a further reminder."

The number of injuries on Norway's offshore facilities declined by almost 80 per cent over the 30 years since 1976, from about 50 per million working hours then to 10 in 2006.

Many factors explain why safety in the oil sector has attracted so much attention from the industry, government and the public, the two professors say.

"The oil business is a heavyweight economic player on which Norway is entirely dependent," observes Prof Lindoe.

"Petroleum has 14 times the export value of fish."

"At the same time, the Norwegian government has declared that this industry will be a world leader for safety. And the newspapers write about oil because people are interested in it."

The lack of such external interest makes safety work much more arduous for fishermen and in maritime transport. Smaller margins also make it more difficult to invest in better equipment, newer vessels or improved training.

Profs Lindoe and Engen also believe that under-reporting of accidents and near misses is a major problem.

"Organisation in each sector also differs," explains Prof Engen. "Fishing vessel owners and crews have traditionally been members of the same union, for example, so that conflicts of interest between safety and costs fail to emerge."

"Safety representatives are seldom to be found, and many vessels belong to family-owned companies where safety is a taboo subject," Engen says.

"Fishermen, like farmers, are also preoccupied with their occupational freedom. Imposed safety measures would meet resistance and have little effect. So the desire to improve must come from the fishermen themselves."

Read more about Risk Management and Societal Safety Research at the University of Stavanger

Related Links
University of Stavanger
Water News - Science, Technology and Politics

Get Our Free Newsletters Via Email
Buy Advertising Editorial Enquiries


. Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Fisherman's gold: Shark fin hunt empties west African seas
Saint Louis, Senegal (AFP) Jan 8, 2012
Retired fisherman Sada Fall is upbeat. His two sons are returning from sea with a boatload of "gold", as he calls shark fins, whose value has near-obliterated the ocean's top predator in these seas. Fall, 62, walks along the beach in this fishing village in the north of Senegal, his blue-grey boubou flapping in the dry, dusty wind, a bright red flowered umbrella shielding him from the scorch ... read more

Haiti quake victims stuck in a time warp

The nuclear, biological and climate threat - 2011 reviewed

'Doomsday' ticks closer on nuclear, climate fears

Haitian PM says 2012 is year of reconstruction

Nokia declares war in US smartphone market

Salk scientists map the frontiers of vision

Hybrid silkworms spin stronger spider silk

Microsoft to bring Kinect to Windows PCs

Differing dangers at sea

Fisherman's gold: Shark fin hunt empties west African seas

Fisherman's gold: Shark fin hunt empties west African seas

Dolphins showing up on world dinner plates

Next Ice Age Delayed For Thousands Of Years Warn Scientists

'Dramatic' loss of harp seals amid warming: study

New species found in deep antarctic waters

Russian river water unexpected culprit behind Arctic freshening

World's 'most expensive' tea grown in Chinese panda poo

Scientists Refute Greenpeace Claims About GM Corn

UF research on newly formed plants could lead to improved crop fertility

KFC owner clears final hurdle to buy China food chain

Could Siberian volcanism have caused the Earth's largest extinction event?

Death toll in Brazil floods, landslide rises to 28

7.3 magnitude quake strikes off western Indonesia: USGS

Netherlands evacuates hundreds as flood fears rise

Boko Haram and U.S. plans in Africa

French experts to report on pre-genocide Rwanda plane attack

Adrenaline rush with a township view at Soweto's towers

Kenyan jets kill '60 or more' Somali Islamist insurgents

To Speed People Up, Human Leg Muscle Slows Down

Brain's Connective Cells Are Much More Than Glue

Commentary: Youth bulge

Spectacular fireworks ring in New Year


The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2012 - Space Media Network. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement