Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Earth Science News .




DEMOCRACY
For pundits, it's better to be confident than correct
by Staff Writers
Pullman WA (SPX) May 29, 2013


Ben Smith, right, and Jadrian Wooten analyzed a billion tweets to demonstrate that pundits are more popular if they are confident than correct. Credit: Courtesy of Washington State University.

It would be nice to think the pundits we see yelling on TV and squawking on Twitter are right all the time. It turns out they're wrong more often than they are right.

Now two Washington State University economics students have demonstrated that it simply doesn't pay as much for a pundit to be accurate as it does to be confident. It's one thing to be a good pundit, but another to be popular.

"In a perfect world, you want to be accurate and confident," says Jadrian Wooten. "If you had to pick, being confident will get you more followers, get you more demand."

Wooten made his discovery with Ben Smith, a fellow economics graduate. Smith originally wanted to test the accuracy and confidence of stock market pundits, taking inspiration from stock watcher and CNBC host Jim Cramer, whom Wooten describes as "the yelling genius that he thinks he is."

But stock predictions rarely come with a date at which one could say a pundit was right or wrong. Sporting events do, so Smith made a software program to sort through more than 1 billion tweets for predictions of the 2012 baseball playoffs and World Series and the 2013 Super Bowl.

The program pulled out tweets with team names, nicknames and expressions commonly associated with predictions, like "beat." Where they might rate the confidence of a television pundit by how loudly he or she yelled, a scale of word strength pegged words like "vanquish," "destroy" and "annihilate" as expressions of confidence.

Their hypothesis: Pundits have a false sense of confidence because that's what the public, seeking to avoid the stress of uncertainty, craves.

"They're trading away some of their accuracy to be a Jim Cramer," says Wooten. "'I might not be right all the time but I can yell louder than this other guy.'"

Wooten and Smith looked at both professional pundits - celebrities with verified Twitter accounts - and amateurs claiming some sports expertise. Both were worse at predicting than the 50-50 odds of a coin toss. Professionals were right 47 percent of the time, a hair better than the 45 percent accuracy of amateurs.

But the professionals were more confident, scoring a .480 confidence rating to the amateurs' .313.

And confidence pays - far better than accuracy.

If a professional pundit accurately predicted every game of the baseball playoffs and series, Wooten and Smith estimated his or her Twitter following would increase 3.4 percent. An amateur would get 7.3 percent more followers.

But a professional whose confidence knows no bounds would increase his or her following by nearly 17 percent and an amateur would see a nearly 20 percent rise in followers.

The outlier of the field could be Nate Silver, the statistician and New York Times political blogger. He's both cautious and accurate. But owing in large part to his correctly calling all 50 states in the recent presidential election, he's popular.

By and large, say Smith and Wooten, pundits get a better audience through confidence and the excitement it generates.

"There is some psychological literature on the idea that people hate uncertainty," says Smith. "The fact that people don't like uncertainty would suggest that they don't like the idea of a Nate Silver sort of person standing up there and saying, 'I'm only 90 percent sure.'"

"I like to think of it like a roulette wheel," says Wooten." If you have somebody just placing bets, that person is kind of boring. But if you have someone going, 'Oh, yeah! It's red!' and they are confident, that's the person that you are interested in."

Smith and Wooten outlined their findings earlier this year at the 50th Annual Meeting of the Academy of Economics and Finance. They plan to publish a paper on their method in an open-source journal, helping researchers, business people and others pose all sorts of questions to the vast amounts of data on the Internet.

.


Related Links
Washington State University
Democracy in the 21st century at TerraDaily.com






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








DEMOCRACY
S.African court to rule on banned Zuma lion advert
Johannesburg (AFP) May 27, 2013
A lobby group on Monday asked a South African court to reinstate an advertisement urging President Jacob Zuma to act against the trade in lion bones, which was removed from the country's main airport. The advert pictured Zuma in the background of a poster of a lioness looking down the barrel of a gun with the text "President Zuma can save her life". The posters were removed from Johannes ... read more


DEMOCRACY
Africa plans emergency force, but can it deliver?

Remembering storm, Obama, Christie again the odd couple

Bill Gates hopeful of more aid from China

Japan nuclear lab accident affected 30: agency

DEMOCRACY
Helicopter-light-beams - a new tool for quantum optics

Just how secure is quantum cryptography

One Year Anniversary of KOMPSAT-3 Launch

Crystal-clear method for distinguishing between glass and fluids

DEMOCRACY
Small dams on Chinese river harm environment more than expected

Source of life running out: water scientists

S. Korea commission to probe $20 bln river project

Spain and France agree on fishing quota swap

DEMOCRACY
Russian scientists make rare find of 'blood' in mammoth

Study explores atmospheric impact of declining Arctic sea ice

The Antarctic polar icecap is 33.6 million years old

Slovenian flyer completes eco-friendly Arctic voyage

DEMOCRACY
Even farm animal diversity is declining as accelerating species loss threatens humanity

China's Shuanghui to buy US pork icon Smithfield

Colombia peace still distant despite a first deal

New research shows that potatoes provide one of the best nutritional values per penny

DEMOCRACY
Small earthquake rocks Wales

Hurricane Barbara hits land in Mexico, two dead

Chile begins evacuation near volcano

Massive Far East quake felt in Moscow, no casualties

DEMOCRACY
Climate change drowning the 'Venice of Africa'

Outside View: Somalia's Jubaland

Nigeria says women, children held by Boko Haram freed

Africa celebrates progress and 50 years of 'unity'

DEMOCRACY
Study: African terrain may have pushed humans into walking on two feet

170,000 living in subdivided flats in Hong Kong: study

Monkey teeth help reveal Neanderthal weaning

China newborn rescued from toilet pipe: report




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement