Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Earth Science News .

Lies, damn lies, and China's economic statistics
by Staff Writers
Beijing, China / China (AFP) Aug 15, 2013

China produces fewer millionaires as economy slows: survey
Shanghai, China / China (AFP) Aug 15, 2013 - China's millionaires, a symbol of the country's growing wealth, increased at their slowest rate in five years in 2012 as the economy and stock market stumbled, a survey showed.

The number of millionaires -- defined as those with personal wealth of at least 10 million yuan ($1.6 million) -- rose just three percent year-on-year to 1.05 million, said the independent Hurun Research Institute and consultancy GroupM Knowledge.

The number of "super-rich" Chinese -- with personal wealth of at least 100 million yuan -- went up only two percent to 64,500, also the slowest pace in five years, according to the survey released on Wednesday.

The slowdown came as growth in the world's second largest economy slipped to a 13-year low of 7.8 percent in 2012.

Only a quarter of Chinese millionaires were "very confident" about the domestic economy in the coming two years, the survey showed, down from 28 percent in 2011 and nearly half of those questioned in 2010.

China's economic growth slipped further to 7.7 percent in the January-March period this year and slowed to 7.5 percent in the second quarter, raising alarm bells over possible deeper weakness.

Beijing, the nation's capital and political centre, had the highest number of millionaires with 184,000, or 17.5 percent of total, the survey said, ahead of the financial hub Shanghai on 147,000.

Stock market sluggishness also contributed to the slower growth of the wealthy population, with the Shanghai exchange's benchmark index gaining only 3.17 percent last year.

About 15 percent -- 160,000 -- of Chinese millionaires named stock investments as their main source of wealth, down five percent from 2011, according to the survey.

Real estate remained Chinese millionaires' top investment choice despite government regulations aimed at cooling the market, the survey said, but they had a growing tendency to seek such investments overseas.

China has soared almost to the top of the world's economic league tables, but whether the official data underpinning its status can be trusted is a constant headache, analysts say.

Simmering unease regarding China's economic figures has taken on new meaning in recent months with discrepancies in some statistics and questions over just how much gross domestic product (GDP) is really growing.

Earlier this year, economists took issue with Chinese monthly trade statistics, which diverged wildly from expectations, and two weeks ago official and private purchasing managers surveys -- a key measure of manufacturing -- surprisingly pointed in opposite directions.

Doubts have also been raised about how inflation is calculated.

"If there was an index for suspicion about China's official statistics, it would be off the charts, or to use the technical American term, 'crazy bad'," Standard Chartered economist Stephen Green wrote in a report.

No less an authority than China's new premier Li Keqiang has expressed doubts on the issue.

Leaked US diplomatic cables show that as the top official in Liaoning province in 2007, he told the then US ambassador that some Chinese data was "man-made" and thus unreliable.

When evaluating the provincial economy, Li said he focused on only three figures -- electricity consumption, rail cargo volume, and the amount of loans issued, according to a confidential memo released by the WikiLeaks website in late 2010.

"All other figures, especially GDP statistics, are 'for reference only,' he said smiling," according to the cable.

China officially overtook Japan as the world's second-largest economy in 2010, and analysts say it is only a matter of time before it knocks the United States off the pedestal it has held for more than a century.

But when that day finally comes, can the data be believed?

Michael Pettis, a finance professor at Peking University and a senior associate at the US-based Carnegie Endowment, said that among China economists, "no one" found Li's purported comments surprising.

"I mean, we've been told this many, many, many times by government officials," he told AFP.

"There's a lot of problems in China. One is that there's a perception that the numbers have political incentives embedded in them."

China calculates monthly and annual data far more quickly than France, a much smaller economy believed to have much higher quality data, he noted.

"So you sort of wonder how they're able to do it more quickly than the French," he said. "That leaves all sorts of questions open."

Economists have long questioned the reliability of numbers provided by local government officials whose career trajectory depends on the performance of their region, creating incentives to make figures look better than the reality.

Toshiya Tsugami, a former Japanese diplomat who now heads a China business consultancy, blames a governmental structure which gives local authorities broad administrative powers but reserves control over assignments and promotions for the centre.

"The personnel ratings are done based mostly on each leader's performance, and what is most given weight is to what extent each local leader has developed his/her local economy, for which purpose the most used measure is GDP," he said.

"As a result, local leaders are engaging in fierce competition aiming at higher GDP growth in order to be promoted," he added. "And since they also handle statistics, there is a strong motivation to dress up the data."

It is widely known that the sum total of growth as reported by each province is much higher than for the country overall, Pettis noted, "which of course is impossible".

"I think there is a sense that the National Bureau of Statistics is doing a reasonably good job under very difficult circumstances," he added. "The local provincial and municipal statistical bureaus, maybe less so."

The report by Green of Standard Chartered, released earlier this year, estimated economic growth for 2011 and 2012 at 7.2 percent and 5.5 percent respectively, far below official figures of 9.3 percent and 7.8 percent.

Acknowledging the inherent challenges he had with his calculations, he wrote that his figures could at best be described as "guesstimates", adding: "We have to use official data to question official data."

Christopher Balding, who teaches at Peking University's HSBC Business School, argued in a paper this month that skewed consumer price index data, especially for housing, seriously overstates the size of China's economy.

"Conservatively, correcting for housing price inflation... adds approximately one percent to annual consumer price inflation in China, reducing real GDP by more than $1 trillion."

But experts say the situation is expected to improve as authorities realise they need a better grip on what is happening to create and carry out effective policies.

China's leaders say they want to change the country's economic model to one more resembling advanced countries such as the US and Japan, where consumer spending is the key growth engine, and that will result in slower, albeit steadier, annual expansions.

Wang Qinwei, China economist at Capital Economics in London, told AFP: "If the data are not reliable, then any policy and reform decisions will be wrong."


Related Links
The Economy

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Cisco to cut 4,000 jobs
New York City, New York (AFP) Aug 14, 2013
Information technology giant Cisco announced Wednesday that it will cut 4,000 jobs, equal to five percent of its workforce. Cisco executives said the cuts were necessitated by a weaker-than-expected economic recovery, with conditions especially disappointing in emerging markets. The "economic recovery is slower and more inconsistent," chief executive John Chambers told analysts. Whil ... read more

Protesters blast Russia's undocumented immigrants detention camps

Fukushima operator pumps out toxic groundwater

Legacy of 1986 Chernobyl disaster seen in impact on region's forests

Dark tourism brings light to disaster zones

Toxicologist says NAS panel 'misled the world' when adopting radiation exposure guidelines

Challenges and Practices for Space Mechanisms - Part 2

New 'weird' material may be new class of solids, researchers say

Large Area Picosecond Photodetectors push timing envelope

Study finds novel worm community affecting methane release in ocean

Tahiti: A very hot biodiversity hot spot in the Pacific

Greenpeace warns Spain about building on coast

Newly discovered bacterial partnership changes ocean chemistry

Greenland ice is melting - also from below

Greenpeace challenges Rosneft vessel in Arctic waters

Arctic sea-ice loss has widespread effects on wildlife

New records for sea ice loss, greenhouse gas in 2012

Fonterra executive resigns after milk scare

New Zealand PM to make milk scare apology in China

Boom in city beekeeping may not help, could hurt Brit honeybee decline

Is sous vide cooking safe?

Cargo ship sinks as Typhoon Utor hits Hong Kong

Philippine rescuers race to help typhoon-hit towns

Russian missing on Indonesian volcano

Japan tsunami ship to be scrapped

Leader of 2012 military coup in Mali promoted

DR Congo colonel defects to M23 rebels with 30 men: army

Four killed in Ethiopian military plane crash in Mogadishu

Congolese soldiers plead not guilty over Brazzaville blast

Facebook boosts connections, not happiness: study

Brain's flexible hub network helps humans adapt

Find indicates Neanderthals capable of making sophisticated bone tools

A new archaeological technique gives insight into the day before death

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement