Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Earth Science News .

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

MSF hospital strike was 'human error': US general
By Guillaume DECAMME
Kabul (AFP) Nov 25, 2015

MSF hospital strike: Shifting statements by US officials
A Timeline

October 3

NATO says a US air strike at 2:15 am local time "may have" hit a hospital run by the medical charity Doctors Without Borders (MSF) in the embattled Afghan city of Kunduz.

"The strike may have resulted in collateral damage to a nearby medical facility. This incident is under investigation," the coalition says.

MSF meanwhile says its trauma centre was struck "several times".

The strike is described as "inexcusable" and possibly criminal by UN rights chief Zeid Ra'ad Al Hussein.

October 4

MSF shuts down its operations in the city and demands an independent investigation into what it calls a war crime. US President Barack Obama meanwhile offers his "deepest condolences" over the attack.

October 5

General John Campbell, the top American commander in Afghanistan, says Afghan forces called in a US air strike on a Kunduz hospital.

"An air strike was then called to eliminate the Taliban threat and several civilians were accidentally struck," he tells reporters.

His remarks prompt MSF to blast "discrepancies" in US accounts of the strike, which it says caused patients to burn to death in their beds and reduced the hospital to smouldering rubble.

October 6

Campbell testifies before the US Senate Armed Services Committee that the hospital was "mistakenly struck", adding that while it was the Afghans who called for the strike, ultimately the decision to launch rested with Americans.

"To be clear, the decision to provide aerial fire was a US decision made within the US chain of command," he says.

October 7

US President Barack Obama calls MSF chief Joanne Liu "to apologise and express his condolences," White House spokesman Josh Earnest tells reporters.

MSF meanwhile demands an international probe.

"We cannot rely on an internal military investigation," Liu tells reporters, insisting that an "international humanitarian fact-finding commission" should probe the attack.

"This was not just an attack on our hospital, it was an attack on the Geneva Conventions," Liu says.

November 5

MSF releases its own harrowing report into the attack, describing patients burning in their beds, medical staff decapitated by shrapnel and a nurse who suffered a "traumatic amputation" in the attack.

People were shot at, apparently from the plane, as they tried to flee the burning building, with some eyewitnesses cited in the report saying the shooting appeared to follow those on the run.

"The view from inside the hospital is that this attack was conducted with a purpose to kill and destroy," MSF general director Christopher Stokes said in Kabul.

The MSF report also details increasingly frantic efforts by its staff to reach NATO and US officials to stop the attack.

November 25

Campbell announces the results of the US investigation into the strike, saying it was "caused primarily by human error" and that the hospital had been "misidentified as a target".

The crew hit the hospital instead of a nearby Afghan intelligence compound that was thought to have been commandeered by Taliban fighters during their brief capture of the northern provincial capital, he says.

Those who requested the strike and those who executed it "did not undertake appropriate measures to verify that the facility was a legitimate military target", he says, vowing that disciplinary action will be taken.

Brigadier General Wilson Shoffner refuses to say if there will be an additional international independent investigation.

"We believe the investigation completed was full and impartial, and we stand by the findings and recommendations," he says.

A deadly air strike on a Doctors Without Borders (MSF) hospital was "caused primarily by human error", the US commander in Afghanistan said Wednesday, prompting a strong rebuke from the charity who slammed American forces for "gross negligence".

The October 3 air raid on the French charity's hospital during a Taliban offensive in the northern city of Kunduz killed at least 30 people, forcing the facility to close and sparking an avalanche of global condemnation.

The "tragic but avoidable accident (was) caused primarily by human error," General John Campbell told reporters at NATO headquarters in Kabul, adding that those most closely associated with the incident had been suspended from their duties.

He blamed in part fatigue of US troops who had been battling a Taliban offensive in Kunduz for five days, adding that the mistake was "compounded by process and equipment failures".

Responding to the release of the investigation, MSF general director Christopher Stokes strongly condemned the actions of the US forces.

"The frightening catalogue of errors outlined today illustrates gross negligence on the part of US forces and violations of the rules of war," Stokes said.

Campbell described how a Special Operations AC-130 gunship aircraft hit the hospital instead of a nearby Afghan intelligence compound that was thought to have been commandeered by Taliban fighters during their brief capture of the northern provincial capital.

Those who requested and executed the strike "did not undertake appropriate measures to verify that the facility was a legitimate military target", he said.

Some of those involved in the attacks failed to follow the rules of engagement, said Brigadier General Wilson Shoffner at the same press conference.

Shoffner refused to say if the US probe would be followed by an additional independent international investigation, which MSF has repeatedly called for.

Stokes reiterated the charity's position, saying the investigation leaves "more questions than answers" and the attack "cannot only be dismissed as individual human error or breaches of the US rules of engagement".

- 29 minutes -

The strike began at 2:08 am local time, Campbell said, and at 2:20 am MSF phoned the US military to report they were under attack.

"It took the headquarters and the US special operations commander until 2:37 am to realise the fatal mistake. At that time, the AC-130 had already ceased firing. The strike lasted for approximately 29 minutes," he added.

The gunship's electronic systems had malfunctioned, he said, cutting off much of its communications, and the aircraft had diverted from its path believing it had been targeted by a missile, degrading the accuracy of "certain target systems".

This meant that when the crew entered the coordinates they were directed to an open field some 300 metres (feet) from the intended target.

"The investigating officer found that the air crew visually located the closest, largest building near the open field which we now know was the MSF trauma centre," Campbell said.

The hospital appeared similar to the description provided of the intended target, and at night the crew was "unable to identify any signs of the hospital's protected status".

"We have learned from this terrible incident," said Campbell.

"We will also take administrative and disciplinary action," he said, adding that those involved would face "standard military justice".

US forces will offer their assistance to MSF in rebuilding the hospital, the only trauma centre in the region, he said.

- Contrasting accounts -

The timeline given by Campbell differed in parts from MSF's own account of the attack, which the charity has said lasted for around an hour.

In an internal review released earlier this month, MSF detailed frantic efforts by its staff to reach US and NATO officials to halt the strike.

According to that report, by 2.37 am -- when Campbell said US officials had realised the mistake -- four phone calls had been made by MSF representatives in Kabul and New York to NATO, the Red Cross, a UN military liaison, and the US defence department.

The calls continued after Campbell said the gunship had stopped firing, with one message at 2.56 am "insisting that the airstrikes stop and informing that we suspected heavy casualties", according to the MSF account.

In the days after the attack the US military offered a series of shifting explanations before President Barack Obama admitted in a call to MSF chief Joanne Liu that it had been a mistake and apologised.

A NATO statement released hours after the attack did not confirm the hospital was targeted, characterising it instead as "collateral damage" as Afghan forces came under fire.

The next day the US confirmed the hospital was hit directly but did not offer further details.

Later General Campbell suggested that Afghan forces had called in the strike, before offering a fourth account admitting US special forces had been in touch with the aircraft.

NATO and the Afghan army are conducting their own investigations.


Thanks for being here;
We need your help. The SpaceDaily news network continues to grow but revenues have never been harder to maintain.

With the rise of Ad Blockers, and Facebook - our traditional revenue sources via quality network advertising continues to decline. And unlike so many other news sites, we don't have a paywall - with those annoying usernames and passwords.

Our news coverage takes time and effort to publish 365 days a year.

If you find our news sites informative and useful then please consider becoming a regular supporter or for now make a one off contribution.

SpaceDaily Contributor
$5 Billed Once

credit card or paypal
SpaceDaily Monthly Supporter
$5 Billed Monthly

paypal only


Related Links
Bringing Order To A World Of Disasters
A world of storm and tempest
When the Earth Quakes

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Previous Report
Preventing famine with mobile phones
Vienna, Austria (SPX) Nov 26, 2015
There are different possible causes for famine and malnutrition--not all of which are easy to foresee. Drought and crop failure can often be predicted by monitoring the weather and measuring soil moisture. But other risk factors, such as socio-economic problems or violent conflicts, can endanger food security too. For organizations such as Doctors without Borders / Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) ... read more

Preventing famine with mobile phones

MSF hospital strike was 'human error': US general

Brazil mining giant rejects UN anger over 'toxic' flood

Children study under open skies as quake rocks education in Pakistan

Creating a new vision for multifunctional materials

3-D printing aids in understanding food enjoyment

Success in producing a completely rare-earth free Feni magnet

Bringing the chaos in light sources under control

River turbines turn Austria's Danube from blue to green

Powerful new global arena needed to confront coming water challenges

Warming ocean worsened Australia's fatal 2011 floods

Fish use smart camouflage mechanism in open ocean waters

Sea level rise from Antarctic collapse may be slower than suggested

Sea ice loss associated with increased summer land use by polar bears

Polar tourists see an icy world melt

New arrivals in Antarctica

Trade may not help a warming planet fight its farming failures

South American origins and spread of the Irish potato famine pathogen

High yield crops a step closer in light of photosynthesis discovery

Going native - for the soil

Flooding brings Qatar to near standstill

Great Barrier Reef protecting against landslides, tsunamis

Hurricane Sandra surges to Category 4 in Pacific

Hidden earthquakes present challenge to earthquake early-warning systems

Pope warns poverty fuels conflict on landmark Africa trip

Huge crowds as pope celebrates first mass in Africa

Massive 'development corridors' in Africa could spell environmental disaster

Pope readies for Africa, riskiest trip of his papacy

Fossilized Homo erectus skull found in China

Clues emerge about the earliest known Americans

Human brains evolved to be more responsive to environmental influences

'Fourth strand' of European ancestry originated with hunter-gatherers isolated by Ice Age

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2017 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement