Stockholm, Sweden (SPX) Feb 04, 2011
Failure to tackle rising greenhouse gas emissions effectively has led to intensifying debate on geoengineering - deliberate large-scale schemes to slow the rate at which Earth is heating up.
The public debate often mixes opinion with fact so scientists have now released the first summary for policymakers on ocean fertilization, one of the earliest geoengineering proposals. The authors report that the chances of success of using ocean fertilization to deal with climate change is low.
Ocean fertilization involves adding iron or other nutrients to the surface of the ocean to trigger growth of microscopic marine plants. These plants use dissolved carbon dioxide to grow, which led to the idea that deliberate fertilization of the ocean on a large scale would remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.
Lead author of the report Professor Doug Wallace from the Leibniz-Institut fur Meereswissenschaften (IFM-GEOMAR) says: "The published findings suggest that even very large-scale fertilization would remove only modest amounts of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere over 100 years".
For two decades, marine scientists have been carrying out a series of small-scale fertilization experiments to understand how ocean ecosystems respond to environmental change.
However the experiments were not designed to address issues relating to geoengineering. Proposals to scale up this approach to slow climate warming or be included within emissions trading schemes to generate carbon credits have stimulated intense debate and criticism amongst scientists and the public.
The new summary, involving independent scientists from seven countries, explains the complexity of the underlying science and brings the detailed findings together in an accessible form for policymakers.
The summary notes that there are still major knowledge gaps. For example, it is unclear whether findings from small-scale experiments apply fully to larger scales. And a major concern is the possibility of large-scale fertilization having unintended consequences for ecosystems. The summary points out the extreme difficulty of assessing long-term effectiveness or unintended side effects.
"It's vastly more complex than assessing carbon storage in a forest" says Wallace "the carbon, and many of the potential impacts, are largely invisible and likely to be spread over vast distances".
Publication of the summary coincides with a symposium in California (La Jolla) on the ecosystem impacts of proposed geoengineering schemes and organized by the International Geosphere-Biosphere Programme. The one-day symposium, streamed live online, will bring together the world's leading experts in this area of research.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
International Geosphere-Biosphere Programme
Water News - Science, Technology and Politics
Strange floating 'blob' found off Florida
Sarasota, Fla. (UPI) Feb 3, 2011
Scientists say an underwater blob of goo off the Florida Panhandle coast isn't oil, but rather a mass of dead plankton, algae and bacteria. The underwater mass of dead sea life, at least three feet thick and spanning 2/3 of a mile off to the coast, appears to be growing as microscopic algae and bacteria get trapped in it and die, the Sarasota (Fla.) Herald-Tribune reported Wednesday. ... read more
Australia sends in troops after mega-cyclone|
Australia flags taxpayer levy for floods
Cyclone Yasi may cost Australia $5 billion: group
'Worst-case' plan saved Australians: officials
Verizon reins in data hogs before unleashing iPhone
New York Times net profit dips 26 percent
A Cool Way To Make Glass
85 percent of US adults own cellphone: survey
Strange floating 'blob' found off Florida
Cyclone adds to Barrier Reef's flood woes
Tropical Atlantic Sees Weaker Trade Winds And More Rainfall
Ocean Fertilization: Summary For Policymakers
VIMS Team Glides Into Polar Research
Greens: Alaska oil delay a win for polar bears
'Hidden Plumbing' Helps Slow Greenland Ice Flow
Study alters Greenland glacier melt view
Philippines rice 2010 farm output hit by weather
Toward Controlling Fungus That Caused Irish Potato Famine
Tiger mauls Indonesian plantation worker to death
UN hopes for fast ratification of biodiversity treaty
Torrential downpours pile misery on Australia
One million Sri Lankans hit by floods, 14 dead
Devastation at epicentre of Australian mega-cyclone
6.4-magnitude quake rocks India-Myanmar border
African nations ride the possibilities of bamboo bikes
Road May Disrupt Migration And Ruin Serengeti
Mutiny by south Sudan ex-militiamen kills 20: army
Suriname president swears-in new army chief
New Age Researchers Highlight How Man Is Changing The World
Mathematical Model Explains How Complex Societies Emerge And Collapse
U.N.: World population rate must slow
'Tsunami' of obesity worldwide: study
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|