Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Earth Science News .

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

Shoddy home renovations may have contributed to Italy quake toll
By Angus MacKinnon and Ljubomir Milasin
Rome (AFP) Aug 28, 2016

When death comes to stay: one Italian village's story
Saletta, Italy (AFP) Aug 27, 2016 - Nowhere was hit harder by the earthquake that brought death and devastation to a remote corner of central Italy this week than Saletta.

And if you listen to the locals, the tiny mountain hamlet is never going to recover from the wounds it has suffered.

In a region which already has its fair share of abandoned villages, that is now the future beckoning for this one, they say.

Fewer than 20 people live full-time in the picturesque hamlet. On Wednesday, with the population temporarily swollen at the height of Italy's summer holiday season, 22 people died.

Stefania Nobile, a petite, white-haired resident, survived. But she doubts the village will.

"The place has been razed to the ground, there's nothing left, nothing," she told AFPTV.

"It's a tragedy, there's nothing left and we don't think it has a future," she said of the tiny locality which lies just north of the tourist town of Amatrice.

"Who would come and spend money here to rebuild?

"It's a shame because it's an amazing area with a beautiful park, people who came to visit from northern Italy and Tuscany for walking holidays."

- 'It's over' -

Marco Beltrame, a lanky 28-year-old who lost his aunt and uncle in the earthquake, agrees.

"The hamlet is dead," he said.

"No-one's going to think about Saletta, they'll only think about Amatrice because Amatrice is big. Saletta will disappear like so many tiny places. It's over."

Beltrame said he might easily have been among the victims.

"I was supposed to have come up that night but didn't at the last minute.

"When I heard about the quake, I rushed here. That house there -- the one that's nothing but a mass of twisted stones -- is my aunt and uncle's house. They never left it, they didn't make it."

Saletta is the kind of place that could easily disappear. It essentially consists of one road loosely associated with a handful of houses dotted about higher up in the hills.

The only apparent communal space is a wooden bus stop, where a handful of survivors shelter from the baking sun while civil protection workers busy themselves sorting provisions in a field on the other side of the road.

- Residents mainly grandparents -

A bit further on, a man was glumly tidying bits of rubble at the entrance to his half-destroyed property, his deflated body language suggesting he was wondering if it was really worth the effort.

In a nearby vegetable patch, the tomatoes have ripened nicely but no-one will ever taste them.

In the garden of the B&B Saletta, washing hung out to dry before the quake was still blowing gently in the breeze.

If Saletta had a focal point, this was perhaps it and now it has gone, along with three people who were trapped inside the half of the building that collapsed.

According to local accounts, one of the dead was a young man who had come up the night before the quake to join his girlfriend and her parents on holiday.

Such bad luck is hard to bounce back from, Stefania Nobile says.

"The inhabitants here were mainly grandparents whose families came to visit from the big cities, especially Rome, in the summer months," she said.

"There could be as many as 250 people here at the height of summer, but fortunately many had left.

"Of the permanent residents, everyone knew everyone of course. There were elderly couples, really good people.

"I don't think any of them survived."

Shoddy, price-cutting renovations, in breach of local building regulations, could be partly to blame for the high death toll from this week's devastating earthquake in central Italy, according to a prosecutor investigating the disaster.

As questions mount over the deaths of nearly 300 people, prosecutor Giuseppe Saieva indicated that property owners who commissioned suspected sub-standard work could be held responsible for contributing to the quake's deadly impact.

Saieva, who works in the Rieti region between Rome and the quake's epicentre, said the tragedy could not simply be filed away as an unavoidable natural disaster.

"If the buildings had been constructed as they are in Japan they wouldn't have collapsed," he told La Repubblica.

Within hours of the quake hitting on Wednesday Saieva was in Amatrice, the small mountain town hit hardest by the quake.

He is inspecting the damage there before opening a preliminary investigation for possible culpable homicide and causing a disaster.

The crushed partition walls of a collapsed three-storey villa were among the sights that caught his eye. "I can only think it was built on the cheap with more sand than cement," he said.

A number of engineering and architectural experts have highlighted the widespread use of relatively cheap cement beams for house extensions and renovations as a possible factor explaining why so many buildings collapsed.

Heavy and inflexible, the cement beams become deadly if released by shaking because they will crush older walls beneath them.

"If it emerges that individuals cut corners, they will be pursued and those that have made mistakes will pay a price," the prosecutor said.

- Centuries old problem -

The issue of whether some of the deaths could have been avoided is particularly acute in the Amatrice area because it is so close (50 kilometres, 32 miles) to L'Aquila, which was hit by a 2009 earthquake in which over 300 people perished.

An outcry over the shoddy, corrupt building practices which led to so many buildings in the university city being inadequately prepared for a quake led to the national Civil Protection agency making almost one billion euros ($1.2 billion) available for upgrading buildings in quake-vulnerable areas.

But the take-up of grants has been low. Critics blame bureaucracy but others maintain that independent-minded villagers will always find the cheapest way of getting their renovations done, whatever the risks.

Some 40 percent of the Italian population, 24 million people, live in zones vulnerable to earthquakes and the risk that entails has been a subject for the country's finest minds for centuries.

As early as the first century, an advisor to the emperor Vespasian, Pliny the elder, was making recommendations on how buildings could be designed to withstand tremors.

And the thicker walls and stone piers that are features of many modern-day quake-proof buildings, were also included in plans drawn up by Renaissance architect Pirro Ligorio in the late 16th century, after southern Italy was devastated by an earthquake that caused 2,000 deaths.

- Huge bill -

Experts however say protecting Italy's unrivalled artistic and architectural heritage is far from straightforward.

"If we start from the idea of upgrading every old building to comparable safety levels of a modern building built to anti-seismic norms, we have to accept that we will never get there," said Paolo Bazzurro, a professor in construction techniques at the University of Pavia.

The trend away from traditional wooden roofs and beams is not the only problem: widening window openings and the removal of reinforcing chains embedded in walls have also contributed.

"These things make buildings more vulnerable," said Bazzurro.

Prime Minister Matteo Renzi has promised to rebuild the hilltop villages devastated by the quake. There will be no repeat of a failed attempt to replace the old communities with new towns elsewhere, which happened after L'Aquila.

"There are lots of technically feasible things that can be done and do not require huge interventions," said Culture Ministry expert Paolo Iannelli.

"Given that towns in the seismic areas have acquired a knowledge of what works over the centuries and generally used the most appropriate materials, it is a question of correcting renovations that have been done over time and have impacted on the resistance of the buildings," he told AFP.

Better and more regular checks on the impact of rain on foundations would be one area where the state could improve its controls, he added.

For houses built before anti-seismic measures became the norm in 1970, it is relatively easy to install shock absorbers, experts say.

But a comprehensive solution will not come cheap. Infrastructure Minister Graziano Delrio was asked last week how much it would cost to bring every building in Italy up to modern anti-quake standards. His answer: 360 billion euros.

Thanks for being here;
We need your help. The SpaceDaily news network continues to grow but revenues have never been harder to maintain.

With the rise of Ad Blockers, and Facebook - our traditional revenue sources via quality network advertising continues to decline. And unlike so many other news sites, we don't have a paywall - with those annoying usernames and passwords.

Our news coverage takes time and effort to publish 365 days a year.

If you find our news sites informative and useful then please consider becoming a regular supporter or for now make a one off contribution.

SpaceDaily Contributor
$5 Billed Once

credit card or paypal
SpaceDaily Monthly Supporter
$5 Billed Monthly

paypal only


Related Links
Bringing Order To A World Of Disasters
When the Earth Quakes
A world of storm and tempest

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Previous Report
Myanmar weighs damage after earthquake rattles Bagan pagodas
Bagan, Myanmar (AFP) Aug 25, 2016
Myanmar took stock of toppled spires and crumbling temple walls in the ancient capital Bagan Thursday after a powerful earthquake hit the country, killing three and damaging the top tourist destination. Two young girls and a man died in Magway region where the 6.8 magnitude quake struck Wednesday evening, cracking buildings across the centre of the country and sending tremors that were felt ... read more

Drawing out children's trauma in quake-hit Italy

Myanmar's Suu Kyi faces test at ethnic peace conference

Obama defends Louisiana flood response

Canada to US tourists: please leave your guns at home

Unraveling the crystal structure of a -70C Celsius superconductor

UNIST to engineer next-generation smart separator membranes

3-D-printed structures 'remember' their shapes

Streamlining accelerated computing for industry

The sound of a healthy reef

Well-wrapped feces allow lobsters to eat jellyfish stingers without injury

Volcanic eruption masked acceleration in sea level rise

Blending wastewater may help California cope with drought

A mammoth undertaking

Giant cruise ship heads to Arctic on pioneering journey

Study measures methane release from Arctic permafrost

Antarctica's past shows region's vulnerability to climate change

Cameroon must halt rubber plantation project: Greenpeace

Stormy outlook hits French wine output

Bonfires light up Baltic coast, with tech-savvy twist

Molecular signature shows plants are adapting to increasing CO2

Hurricane Lester, TS Madeline strengthen in the Pacific

Shoddy home renovations may have contributed to Italy quake toll

Strong typhoon Lionrock heads for Japan's northeast

Myanmar weighs damage after earthquake rattles Bagan pagodas

S.Sudan court martials 60 soldiers

Conflict and drought threaten Mozambique's Gorongosa park

Boko Haram's Shekau 'wounded' in air strike: Nigeria

Japan takes aid show to Africa in China's shadow

Scientists think human ancestor Lucy fell from a tree

The Anthropocene is here: scientists

PRB projects world population rising 33 percent by 2050 to nearly 10 billion

Chimpanzees choose cooperation over competition

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2017 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement