Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Earth Science News .

Subscribe free to our newsletters via your

UN climate report: already out of date

by Staff Writers
Paris (AFP) Nov 11, 2007
Fresh from winning the Nobel Peace Prize, the UN's top scientific panel on climate change will meet in the Spanish port city of Valencia Monday to finalise a landmark report on global warming and how to avoid its worst ravages.

But beneath its newly-won fame, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is under intensifying scrutiny about some of its key processes.

Some voices, including from within the IPCC itself, fear the panel's grand report will be badly out of date before it is even printed. Others quietly criticise the organisation as being too conservative in its appreciation of the climate threat.

The document to be issued in Valencia next Friday boils down a 2,500-page, three-volume assessment issued earlier this year, the first IPCC review of climate change since 2001.

The upcoming "synthesis report," comprising a summary for policymakers of 25 pages, and a technical document of around 70 pages, puts in a nutshell the evidence for climate change, its likely impacts and the options for tackling it.

The analysis carries huge political weight. It will be a compass for guiding action on climate change for years to come, starting with a crucial UN conference in Bali next month.

But some experts are worried, fearing that the IPCC's ponderous machinery, which gives birth to a new review only every five or six years, is falling dangerously behind with what's happening to Earth's climate systems.

The new report notably fails to take into account a batch of dramatic recent evidence, including the shrinkage of the Arctic ice cap, glacier loss in Greenland, a surge in levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) and an apparent slowing of Earth's ability to absorb greenhouse gases, they say.

Taken together, say the sources, these phenomena suggest climate change is be occurring faster than expected -- and may even unleash "tipping points" that could uncontrolably accelerate the damage.

"Over the past several years we have realized ... that the speed at which changes can occur -- such as ice sheet disintegration and resulting sea level rise -- is much faster than IPCC has estimated," leading climatologist James Hansen, who heads the NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York, told AFP.

"We are now in a situation where the luxury of super-caution and reticence poses a danger for the planet and all its creatures," he said.

French scientist Jean Jouzel, who has been deeply involved in the IPCC report, acknowledges that its estimates about rising sea levels -- which could affect hundreds of millions of people -- are half of what more recent studies indicate.

Another weakness of the IPCC, say others, is a tendency to shy away from controversy.

The more forceful the panel's conclusions, the more pressure it will put on policymakers to adopt measures -- some of them politically costly -- ranging from carbon taxes and mandatory caps on CO2 emissions to massive investment in renewable energy.

Too often, draft text that highlights the possible consequences of warming gets watered down in the final version, say these critics.

British scientist James Lovelock blames the consensus rule that governs IPCC proceedings, enabling government representatives to meddle with "forthright and inconvenient forecasts" made by experts.

"The IPCC has a history and a habit of ignoring many of the big issues that hint at policy or policy analysis," agreed Tom Downing, director of the Oxford Office of the Stockholm Environment Institute and a lead author of the report.

He pointed to the draft report to be hammered out in Valencia, saying it had "barely a page" on vulnerability to climate change and how to cope with it.

The IPCC, jointly launched 20 years ago by the UN Environmental Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO), shared this year's Nobel Peace Prize with former US vice president Al Gore.

Pep Canadell, executive director of the Global Carbon Project based in Australia, says the panel's caution and rigour had helped create awareness that climate change was a genuine and pressing issue.

But it was time for the IPCC to move to a faster and more assertive track, Canadell suggested.

"We are no longer in the business of convincing governments that the problem is real," he told AFP. "The issue now is what to do and how fast it needs to be done."

Email This Article
Comment On This Article

Related Links
Climate Science News - Modeling, Mitigation Adaptation

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Rich nations must pay more for climate change aid
Lisbon (AFP) Nov 9, 2007
Rich countries must give poor nations more aid to help them overcome the impact of global warming, international experts have told an EU conference.

  • Electronic Nose Could Detect Hazards
  • Court upholds jail term for Japanese architect
  • SkyPort Signs Contract With Cisco For Emergency Response Satellite Connectivity
  • GETAC To Showcase Fully Rugged PCs At Firerescue 2007 Conference And Exposition

  • Global warming: Oceans could absorb far more CO2, says study
  • UN climate report: already out of date
  • Rich nations must pay more for climate change aid
  • Global-warming gases set to rise by 57 percent by 2030: IEA

  • SPOT - The World's First Satellite Messenger Now Shipping
  • Fujifilm Unveils GPS-Based Data Tape Tracker
  • Vacation Photos Create 3D Models Of World Landmarks
  • NASA Data May Help Improve Estimates Of A Hurricane's Punch

  • Marquiss Wind Power Appoints Former Senior Intel And Flextronics Executive As CEO
  • Geothermal Energy Licence Granted
  • PPL Partners With Vermont Landfill To Develop Renewable Energy Generating Facility
  • Autodesks Architecture Solutions Simplify Sustainable Design For China Project

  • Bug-Zapper: A Dose Of Radiation May Help Knock Out Malaria
  • Failed AIDS vaccine may have increased infection risk
  • NASA Technology Helps Predict And Prevent Future Pandemic Outbreaks
  • Deadly HIV-TB co-epidemic sweeps sub-Saharan Africa: report

  • Researchers Successfully Simulate Photosynthesis And Design A Better Leaf
  • Exceptions Prove Rule Of Tropical Importance In Biodiversity
  • Massive Project Reveals Shortcomings Of Modern Genome Analysis
  • For Migrating Sparrows, Kids Have A Compass, But Adults Have The Map

  • Oil spill in Russia an 'ecological catastrophe': experts
  • Storm smashes Russian oil tanker, causing 1,300-tonne spill
  • Pollution From Marine Vessels Linked To Heart And Lung Disease
  • Higher Levels Of Pollutants Found In Fish Caught Near A Coal-Fired Power Plant

  • One-child Chinese families prefer it that way
  • Key To False Memories Uncovered
  • Computers Learn Art Appreciation
  • Research Project May Revolutionize Apparel Industry

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement