Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Earth Science News .




Subscribe to our free daily newsletters



We Are All Microbes - Part Two

Fluorescence micrographs of cyanobacteria. About 2 billion years ago, cyanobacteria - oxygen-producing photosynthetic prokaryotes that used to be called blue-green algae - were responsible for launching the process that increased the concentration of atmospheric oxygen from less than 1 percent to about 20 percent today, making possible the evolution of humans and other animals. Credit: Mary Sarcina University College London
for Astrobiology Magazine
An Interview with Lynn Margulis
Moffett Field (SPX) Oct 06, 2006
Microcosmos: Four Billion Years of Microbial Evolution, co-authored by Lynn Margulis and her son Dorion Sagan, was first published twenty years ago. Astrobiology Magazine recently interviewed Margulis, to find out how her and Sagan's ideas have stood the test of time. In this, the second part of a four-part interview, she talks about four specific microbial organisms that, through fusion, yielded modern plant and animal cells.

Astrobiology Magazine: In Microcosmos, you detailed four specific microorganisms that you thought were involved, through symbiogenesis, in the creation of various eukaryotic cells, the type of cells that animals and plants are made of. At the time, those ideas were not well accepted. Has that changed?

Lynn Margulis: Well, we've won three out of four.

Nobody today doubts that chloroplasts began as cyanobacteria. Chloroplasts are the little green dots in the cells of plants and algae, in which all photosynthesis occurs. Photosynthesis, the conversion of sunlight as energy to food and cell material, is fundamentally a bacterial virtuosity. It began in a specific group of oxygen-producing photosynthetic bacteria that, by definition, are cyanobacteria.

If they're green, they're photosynthetic. They make food only in the sunlight, because they require sunlight for their source of energy. They take carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere, and fix it, that is, chemically change it to food and body, and they produce oxygen as waste. That series of changes is done by cyanobacteria exclusively. They're the only organisms that can make the oxygen and make the food that everything else needs.

Well, you say, can't plants do that? And the answer is yes, but plants are something that hold up cyanobacteria. That's all plants are. It's the cyanobacteria in the plants that do that transformation. You say, well, can't algae in the water, green water scum, can't they do it? And the answer is, yes, but the algae are something that brings the little green things inside the scum to the light. So the answer is: nothing but cyanobacteria can make our food and produce our oxygen.

We like to call them the greater bacteria, or the greatest bacteria, because they are. And they're in only three forms: they're in cyanobacteria (what used to be called blue-green algae) all by themselves; or they're in algae; or they're in plants. But fundamentally, if you cut them out of the plant cell, and throw away the rest of the plant cell, the little green dot is the only thing that can do that oxygen production.

That is the greatest achievement of life on Earth, and it occurred extremely early in the history of life. Who knows whether it's 3 billion years ago, or 2.7 billion, or 3.5 billion, but it's that kind of time. And the idea that those little organelles, those little bodies inside of cells, started as free-living cyanobacteria is completely accepted by everybody who even thinks about these problems.

So that's one out of four.

AM: Number two is mitochondria, right?

LM: Yes. Mitochondria are little dots inside the cells of animals and plants and fungi, and all sorts of other organisms with hard names--those mitochondria are where the oxygen is actually respired. Mammals, including people, take oxygen out of the air into the bloodstream, and carry the oxygen all over the body, to all the cells. Inside each cell, the oxygen reacts with hydrogen atoms that are stripped off food as the food is converted into body parts and used for energy.

This oxidation of the foodstuffs is carried out by little particles, the mitochondria, that are one micron, the size of bacteria, inside the animal cell, inside the plant cell, inside the amoeba cell, inside the mushroom cell, and so on. That's what respiration is, and that respiration comes from bacteria that used to be free-living. We know a lot about those bacteria. They used to be able to swim, they used to be able to break down glucose all by themselves, etc. The idea is that mitochondria are from bacteria was harder to accept, but it's now acceptable.

So that's two out of four.

AM: Okay, and number three?

LM: Well, then the question is, What type of cell incorporated the mitochondria, and eventually the chloroplasts, some of them, into itself? What was the original eukaryotic cell? The original cell was an archaebacterium. It was sulfanogenic; it made hydrogen sulfide. We have just reviewed the evidence for that. People are not against that idea at all, because there's a lot of molecular biological evidence for that.

So that's three out of four.

AM: And what's the fourth one? What's left?

LM: The problem I'm still wrestling with is the origin of cilia, which are exactly the same in cross-section as sperm tails. That's the piece that's not been proven, the origin of the wiggly things. They all have strikingly identical 9-fold symmetry in cross-section, so it makes them easily identifiable. We believe the origin of that cell structure is from a free-living organism called a spirochete. That's the part that has been rejected, based on the usual nothing - based on prejudice.

If you look at Microcosmos, you'll see what we call spirochetal secret agents. But it's harder to put your mind around. You don't often hear of this connection between free-living bacteria and the movement inside cells, because there are so many different names associated with these motile structures. Historically they were approached by such different people in so many different studies in so many different fields and so many different countries.

Spirochetes are infamous because they are know to be the infectious agents of both syphilis and Lyme disease, and periodontal diseases are associated with oral spirochetes. Four of the spirochetes have been sequenced, because they're of medical interest.

But a colleague (through the literature only - we don't know her) named Galena Dubinina, a senior-level microbiologist at Moscow University, has sequenced the relevant spirochetes, the ones that can be directly compared with what we're claiming grew into being the cilia. And so what we are working on is either confirming or negating our predictions about the free-living version.

We have these organelles, the cilia, on the cells. We now have, because of her work, the right spirochetes to study the sequences in, and we have very explicit predictions. We're trying to do that comparison, which is exactly what was done to prove the mitochondrial ancestry from the alpha-Proteobacteria, and the chloroplast ancestry from the Cyanobacteria.

Those same types of arguments are now, for the first time, usable to prove the spirochete origin of cilia. So that's what we want to do, confirm that last, fourth prediction. We want to win four out of four.

Related Links
Explore The Early Earth at TerraDaily.com
Darwin Today At TerraDaily.com
Beyond Sol

Unique Gene Regulation Gives Chilly Bugs Survival Advantage
Columbus OH (SPX) Oct 06, 2006
The larvae of Antarctic midges never stop producing special proteins that minimize environmental stress, allowing them to withstand a range of intense environmental conditions in one of the world's harshest environments.







  • Year Of 'Quake Jihad' For Pakistan Militants
  • Musharraf Slams Oxfam Over Pakistan Quake Warning
  • Pakistan Earthquake Reconstruction On Track
  • WFP Creates Emergency Aid Hubs To Improve Disaster Response

  • Arctic Sea Ice Declines Again In 2006
  • Arctic Fever Getting Hotter
  • Dinosaurs' Climate Shifted Too
  • NASA Study Finds World Warmth Edging Ancient Levels

  • NASA Satellite Data Helps Assess the Health of Florida's Coral Reef
  • Alcatel Alenia Space To Build SIRAL-2 Radar Altimeter For CryoSat-2
  • Earth from Space: The French Frigate Shoals
  • European Microsatellite Playing Major Role In Scientific Studies

  • Air Force Making Progress On Alternative Fuels
  • Norway Plans Three-Billion-Dollar Fund For Renewables
  • California Navy Base Reaches Milestone Using Solar Power
  • Technology Can Solve Energy Supply And Security Problems

  • West Java Goes Own Way On Avian Flu Management
  • A Biocontrol Agent Which Doesn't Trigger Antibiotic Resistance
  • US, Australian Scientists Develop Vaccine Against Deadly Viruses
  • 'Killer' B Cells Provide New Link In The Evolution Of Immunity

  • We Are All Microbes - Part Two
  • Unique Gene Regulation Gives Chilly Bugs Survival Advantage
  • New Plant Family Tree Sheds Light On Evolution Of Life Cycles
  • Home, Home On The Range: How Much Space Does An Animal Really Need

  • Canada Will Not Buy Pollution Rights
  • Tonnes Of Garbage Dumped, Thousands Get Lost On Tiananmen Square
  • Tonnes Of Garbage Dumped, Thousands Get Lost On Tiananmen Square
  • Coastal Urbanisation Turning Oceans Into Garbage Dumps Says UN

  • Chinese Oldest Academy Celebrates 1,030 Years
  • Identity Of Ancient Child Skeleton Found In Ethiopia Challenged
  • Family Tree Of Confucius Has One And A Half Million Members
  • Chinese Organ Sales 'Thriving'

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement