Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
. Earth Science News .

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

Will naming the Anthropocene lead to acceptance of our planet-level impact
by Staff Writers
Bethlehem PA (SPX) Feb 28, 2017

This floodwall protecting Cape Girardeau Missouri during a flood in 2013 provides an example of technological hubris says David Casagrande, associate professor of anthropology at Lehigh University (Bethlehem, PA). Image courtesy of David Casagrande

"What's in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet." This phrase - from William Shakespeare's tragic play Romeo and Juliet - is among the most famous acknowledgements in Western culture of the power of naming to shape human perception.

According to the International Union of Geological Sciences (IUGS), the professional organization that defines Earth's time scale, the current time belongs to an epoch named the Holocene - which began 11,500 years ago after the last ice age. However, in recent years, many scientists have advocated to name a new epoch to more accurately reflect the idea that humans have become the dominant planet-shaping force. The name they have proposed places humankind's actions - and their consequences - squarely at the center: the Anthropocene - anthropo, for "man," and cene, for "geological epoch."

The need to name a new epoch is gaining wide acceptance as most experts agree that this time period has been marked by geologically significant changes brought about by human activities, such as an accelerated rate of species extinction and changes in the chemical composition of the atmosphere, oceans and soils. The Working Group on the Anthropocene (WGA) - an international group of planetary scientists - voted to formally designate the epoch Anthropocene and presented the recommendation at IUGS' International Geological Congress in August of last year.

Does a name in itself have sufficient symbolic power to cause a paradigm shift in how humans perceive our role in the changing geological patterns of the planet?

That is among the questions with which David Casagrande, associate professor of anthropology at Lehigh University and his colleagues grapple in their latest article in Anthropology Today: "Ecomyopia in the Anthropocene." The authors cite a previously stated belief that "...a major impediment to action on climate change is the deeply entrenched belief that humans are not capable of planetary-scale impacts."

The researchers identify two possible consequences to the naming of the Anthropocene epoch. One is that it draws attention to humankind's impact on the planet and thus encourages action on climate change. Another is that it contributes to society's faith in technology and the "manifest destiny" of the human domination of nature - an idea the authors label "technological hubris."

"The definition for ecomyopia is the tendency for societies to ignore, not recognize, or fail to act on new ecological information that contradicts political arrangements, social norms, or world views," says Casagrande. "The failure to meaningfully address climate change is a spectacular example of ecomyopia."

The authors employ a social science approach known as longue duree to explore the topic. Pioneered by French scholars in the early 20th century - and carried on by French historian Fernand Braudel - longue duree refers to a method of studying history focused on cycles and slowly-evolving social structures, as opposed to viewing historical events as the consequence of immediate causes.

They apply this approach to Casagrande's research on agriculture and the flooding of homes, farms and businesses in the floodplain along the Mississippi River in the American Midwest.

From the article: "We apply confirmed generalizations to a specific case that links agricultural production in the American Midwest to hydrological change in the Mississippi River Basin. We use this case study as a template for speculating on the impact of the Anthropocene more broadly. Our case study suggests that the concentration of financial capital via agricultural consolidation under pressure of international commodities trade promotes technological hubris. As capital and power concentrate around the world, technological hubris is also likely to become more widely entrenched."

"Ecomyopia" and the Mississippi River flooding
Casagrande, a cultural anthropologist, studies the cognitive dissonance behind climate change denial. Cognitive dissonance is a psychological term to describe the discomfort that is experienced when a person or group of persons hold a set of conflicting beliefs.

"My research focuses on how in conversation we use techniques to avoid these logical contradictions rather than create change," says Casagrande. "One such technique is to shift the conversation to more abstract concepts or themes that cannot be logically evaluated."

In their analysis, the researchers look at some possible causes of "ecomyopia" and reference the idea that technological development produces hierarchical complexity that leads to the consolidation of power and wealth.

The researchers write: "Key decision-makers are often spatially or politically removed from the ecologies they create. Complexity also encourages decisions to be made in short time frames - like quarterly profits, annual harvests, or election cycles - the cumulative effect of which is an inability to react to long-term trends like climate change or the increasing frequency of disastrous flooding in the American Midwest."

In the case of the floodplain along the Mississippi River in the American Midwest, the authors cites research demonstrating its transformation by dams, levees and drainage and its conversion to agriculture and note that the frequent flooding of private and public lands in the area illustrates that attempts to control the river have failed.

To examine community members' responses to this reality, Casagrande combined qualitative data from 121 interviews and five focus groups with farmers, homeowners, business owners, elected officials and government personnel in the area with a quantitative survey of 5,000 households and found three common themes:

* Nearly every stakeholder understands that the hydrology of the Mississippi River is changing and that flooding is occurring more frequently; * There is a widespread aversion to relocating homes and businesses away from flood-prone areas; and,

* Most stakeholders prefer solutions in harmony with processes perceived as natural, such as restoring wetlands or removing or modifying agricultural levees to allow for more storage of water on agricultural land during floods

The authors note that the agricultural community vehemently rejects any option that would take land out of production.

"A fundamental source of political power, from tribal leaders through contemporary political leaders, is the ability to steer the political discourse away from logical contradictions," explains Casagrande. "One negative consequence is that societies on this path tend to invest more in symbolism than actually addressing their real problems."

The authors state: "The agricultural lobby along the Mississippi River has successfully framed public discussion around which largescale infrastructures are most useful for flood control and how they should to be financed."

They add later in the article: "The Midwestern agricultural lobby's successful framing of the flood discourse is possible mainly because of the American cultural faith in technology and capitalism."

Though Casagrande found that people in the community prefer solutions in line with nature, he also found that they are willing to accept the large infrastructural solutions offered by the agricultural industry and policymakers.

The authors state: "The research on flooding in the American Midwest reveals an underlying conflict between the desire for natural solutions to flooding and faith in technological solutions...When asked to think about the potential conflict between natural and technical solutions, people may invoke phrases like 'I don't know - it's just part of God's plan', or 'if they can put a man on the moon, they can solve the flooding problem.'"

Casagrande analyzed community narratives to identify abstract, deeply-held beliefs that community members who were interviewed employed to deal with cognitive dissonance.

"These analyses reveal that, in times of psychological stress, Americans rely heavily on their faith in the technological fix for consolation," the researchers conclude in the paper. Rampant technological hubris and the power of capital to organize social relationships preclude the ability of the Anthropocene to encourage a sustainable world view in which humans are equal to nature."

Balancing optimism and evidence
Using the American Midwest case study as an example, the authors conclude that global capitalism is too strong a force to enable humanity to overcome technological hubris - despite the new Anthropocene label. They acknowledge that optimism on this issue depends entirely on one's faith in the human potential to use technology wisely.

Casagrande and his colleagues compare the possible public response to the Anthropocene label to the reaction to the first photographs of Earth from outer space in 1972. They say that though the photographs altered people's perception of the planet, it has "...failed to temper the power of technological hubris or the unrelenting human transformation of the planet."

From the paper's conclusion: "...the ability for the Anthropocene concept to shift paradigms is not particularly relevant from the longue duree perspective. Under this scenario, the cycle of social collapse is merely scaled up to the planet. One's optimism here depends on how critical one is of the current global techno-capitalist enterprise."

Research paper

Tiny fibers open new windows into the brain
Boston MA (SPX) Feb 24, 2017
For the first time ever, a single flexible fiber no bigger than a human hair has successfully delivered a combination of optical, electrical, and chemical signals back and forth into the brain, putting into practice an idea first proposed two years ago. With some tweaking to further improve its biocompatibility, the new approach could provide a dramatically improved way to learn about the functi ... read more

Related Links
Lehigh University
All About Human Beings and How We Got To Be Here

Thanks for being here;
We need your help. The SpaceDaily news network continues to grow but revenues have never been harder to maintain.

With the rise of Ad Blockers, and Facebook - our traditional revenue sources via quality network advertising continues to decline. And unlike so many other news sites, we don't have a paywall - with those annoying usernames and passwords.

Our news coverage takes time and effort to publish 365 days a year.

If you find our news sites informative and useful then please consider becoming a regular supporter or for now make a one off contribution.

SpaceDaily Contributor
$5 Billed Once

credit card or paypal
SpaceDaily Monthly Supporter
$5 Billed Monthly

paypal only

Comment on this article using your Disqus, Facebook, Google or Twitter login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Haitians' ire over carnival spending amid hurricane's ruins

Carnival helps Rio put crime, recession on back burner

Study shows parks, greenways may help reduce crime in Chicago

Canada conservationist warns of 'cyber poaching

Two radar eyes are better than one

New use for paper industry's sludge and fly ash in plastics

Scientists discover how essential methane catalyst is made

New polymer additive could revolutionize plastics recycling

Calculating recharge of groundwater more precisely

New urgency in fight to restore Florida Everglades

Saab to provide support for Swedish navy underwater systems

First direct measurements of Pacific seabed sediments reveal strong methane source

Air pollution may have masked mid-20th Century sea ice loss

International team reports ocean acidification spreading rapidly in Arctic Ocean

Arctic sea ice decline influences European weather

Simple rule predicts when an ice age ends

Widely accepted vision for agriculture may be inaccurate, misleading

'Our daily bread' has hidden climate costs

What's the buzz on bee parasites?

Brexit sows seeds of doubt for British farmers

An insight into a physical phenomenon that leads to earthquakes

Water slowly restored in Chile capital after deadly floods

California requests $440 mn for flood control after dam crisis

Four million without water in deadly Chile floods

France sends backup to Niger after 16 troops killed

UN airstrikes in C.Africa target 'heavily armed' militia

16 killed in three days of DR Congo clashes

I.Coast hosting bid to save its last chimpanzees

Newfound primate teeth take a big bite out of the evolutionary tree of life

Study shows ancient humans arrived in South America in multiple waves

Will naming the Anthropocene lead to acceptance of our planet-level impact

Tiny fibers open new windows into the brain

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2017 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement