. Earth Science News .
Analysis: DHS will use odor as biometric

"None of the biometrics for identity have worked very well, with the possible exception of DNA," Barry Steinhardt, director of the ACLU's technology and liberty project, said, adding that even fingerprint evidence was "increasingly being challenged in courts around the country. This shows the misplaced priorities (of DHS)," he said. "The government doesn't need to take us down another blind alley."
by Shaun Waterman
Washington (UPI) Mar 9, 2009
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security plans to study the possibility that human body odor could be used to tell when people are lying or to identify individuals in the same way that fingerprints can.

In a federal procurement document posted Friday on the Web, the department's Science and Technology Directorate said it would conduct an "outsourced, proof-of-principle study to determine if human odor signatures can serve as an indicator of deception. … As a secondary goal, this study will examine … human odor samples for evidence to support the theory that an individual can be identified by that individual's odor signature."

Officials said that the work was at a very early stage, but the announcement brought criticism from civil liberties advocates who said it showed the department's priorities were misplaced.

The procurement notice said the department is already "conducting experiments in deceptive behavior and collecting human odor samples" and that the research it hopes to fund "will consist primarily of the analysis and study of the human odor samples collected to determine if a deception indicator can be found."

"This research has the potential for enhancing our ability to detect individuals with harmful intent," the notice said. "A positive result from this proof-of-principle study would provide evidence that human odor is a useful indicator for certain human behaviors and, in addition, that it may be used as a biometric identifier."

DHS spokeswoman Amy Kudwa told United Press International that "proof of concept" work was the very earliest stage of technological development.

The directorate "is trying to determine what factors of human behavior and chemistry can provide clues to the intent to deceive," she said, adding that the work would be carried out by the Federally Funded Research and Development Center run by the non-profit Mitre Corp., which conducts cutting-edge research for U.S. military, homeland security and intelligence agencies.

Barry Steinhardt, director of the ACLU's technology and liberty project, told UPI that the plan showed the department had "misplaced priorities."

"The history of DHS' deployment of these technologies has been one colossal failure after another," he said. "There is no lie detector. This research has been a long, meandering journey, which has taken us down one blind alley after another."

Steinhardt added that even well-established biometric-identity technologies like fingerprinting have resulted in individuals being inaccurately identified, like Oregon lawyer Brandon Mayfield, who got an apology from the FBI after being wrongfully accused of having had a hand in the 2004 Madrid rail bombings.

"None of the biometrics for identity have worked very well, with the possible exception of DNA," he said, adding that even fingerprint evidence was "increasingly being challenged in courts around the country."

"This shows the misplaced priorities (of DHS)," he said. "The government doesn't need to take us down another blind alley."

Recent scientific research shows that so-called volatile organic compounds present in human sweat, saliva and urine can be analyzed using a technique known as gas chromatography-mass spectrometry.

Research published by the Royal Society in London in 2006 found "a substantial number of marker compounds (in human sweat) that can potentially differentiate individuals or groups."

Researchers took five samples each from 179 individuals over a 10-week period and analyzed them, finding hundreds of chemical markers that remained more or less constant for each individual over time.

An analysis of these compounds "found strong evidence for individual (odor) fingerprints," the researchers concluded.

However, they warned that some individuals appear to have less distinctive odors than others, adding that "the reason for the variation in distinctiveness is unclear." More importantly, some individuals' odors changed during the course of the study. "Not all subjects had consistent marker compounds over time, which might be due to physiological, dietary or other changes," the researchers concluded.

The researchers also cautioned that some of these marker compounds might be "exogenous chemical contaminants" from skin-care or perfume products or tobacco smoke and other substances present in an individual's environment. About a quarter of the 44 apparently distinctive marker compounds they were able to analyze appeared to be artificial contaminants, the researchers said.

"Determining the origins of individual and sex-specific odors -- and controlling exogenous chemical contaminants -- may provide the most important challenge for future … studies," the researchers said.

Those challenges are likely to be significant, and they will multiply if the techniques are deployed in the field.

"While some of these sensors perform well in the lab, the real world may be different," technology consultant and author John Vacca said. "The technology is still in its infancy."

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
The Long War - Doctrine and Application



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


A Perverted Interpretation Of History Part Two
Washington (UPI) Mar 6, 2009
Poverty is a contributing factor, not the cause of fanaticism. Poverty is not at the root of fundamentalist ideologies. While hopelessness, a consequence of poverty, may be a strong factor facilitating recruitment for radical causes, poverty in and of itself cannot explain why people are converted to extreme ideologies.







  • China still mum on number of students killed in quake
  • Corruption linked to China TV tower blaze: report
  • Landslide kills schoolchildren in PNG
  • Pilot in California crash opted to fly over homes

  • Arctic Wars Set To Heat Up Part Four
  • Could climate prove a change too far for Obama?
  • 'Albatross' gone, India offers hand to US
  • Washington new center of global warming battle

  • Scientists Expose Buried Fault That Caused Deadly 2003 Quake
  • GOES-O Satellite Arrives At KSC For Final Pre-Launch Testing
  • Three ESA Earth Science Missions Move To Next Phase
  • Earth-Observing Landsat 5 Turns 25

  • China insists gas field its own business despite Japanese protests
  • Analysis: Nigeria oil strike looming
  • Analysis: Ukraine-Russia gas dispute
  • Nigeria: potential gas hotspot, on frontline for climate change

  • Hong Kong bird tests positive for H5N1
  • Wild birds likely caused HK H5N1 outbreak: official
  • Update Presented On Disease In Pork Plant Workers
  • Predicting When Invasive Species Can Travel More Readily By Air

  • Russian elite use choppers to hunt rare wildlife: activists
  • New footage shows rare rhinos in Indonesia: WWF
  • Tiger kills ninth man in Indonesia: official
  • Quarter of antelope species face extinction: IUCN

  • Six firms agree to stop using chemical in baby bottles
  • Bulgarian air most polluted in Europe: ministry
  • Pilot of ship in San Francisco spill pleads guilty
  • Nitrogen And Phosphorus Reductions Needed To Combat Eutrophication

  • Malaysian archaeologists find site of pre-Angkor civilisation
  • Evidence Appears To Show How And Where Frontal Lobe Works
  • Chilli Peppers Continue To Help Unravel Mechanism Of Pain Sensation
  • Analysis: Congress on Mex border violence

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement