. Earth Science News .
Animal Welfare Groups Sues US Navy Over Sonar Harm To Whales

The sonar works by flooding large areas of the ocean with loud bursts of sound, which researchers say has caused hearing loss and organ damage in whales and can harm other marine mammals.

Los Angeles (AFP) Oct 20, 2005
American environmental groups on Wednesday sued the US Navy over its use of a type of ear-splitting sonar that they say can cause internal bleeding and even death in whales and dolphins.

The coalition of groups claims the navy's use of "active sonar" to detect submarines and other underwater objects in areas inhabited by protected marine creatures violates the US law.

The sonar works by flooding large areas of the ocean with loud bursts of sound, which researchers say has caused hearing loss and organ damage in whales and can harm other marine mammals.

"There is no serious scientific dispute that the mid-frequency active sonar systems used by the navy can kill, injure and disturb marine mammals," stated the suit, which is supported by former James Bond star Pierce Brosnan.

"The available scientific data also strongly suggest a long-standing correlation between naval exercises and the mass stranding of beaked whales, going back decades," added the complaint filed in Los Angeles.

The plaintiffs, including the Natural Resources Defense Council and famed French oceanographer Jacques Cousteau's son, Jean-Michel Cousteau, are challenging the use of active sonar that uses mid-range sonic frequencies.

They accuse the navy of violating the National Environmental Policy Act, which requires the preparation of an environmental assessment report for major government actions that have an impact on the environment.

The groups also accuse the navy of flouting the Endangered Species Act, which orders the government to ensure that its actions do not jeopardize any endangered species, as well as the Marine Mammal Protection Act, which makes it a crime to disturb marine mammals.

A Navy representative could not immediately be reached to comment on the lawsuit.

In addition to seeking environmental analysis of the mid-frequency sonar's use, the plaintiffs seek to force the navy to take precautions, such as avoiding important whale habitat when testing or training with the sonar.

"This is not a question of environment versus national security," Joel Reynolds, a lawyer for Natural Resources Defense Council, told reporters.

"We can have both and we must have both because that's what the law requires."

The lawsuit follows a similar complaint over lower-frequency sonar that was settled two years ago.

The environmentalists acknowledge that not much is publicly known about the high-intensity sonar systems, which are used by navies across the world.

But they said in their suit that the sonar was capable of generating up to 215 decibels.

In 2000, seven whales were found dead on a beach and others were stranded in the Bahamas after the US Navy allegedly used sonar reported to have exceeded a whopping 235 decibels, the groups say.

Since then, the US Navy has continued using the sonar, including on a training mission off the coast of the eastern state of North Carolina in January that took place in waters inhabited by endangered or threatened species, the suit said.

In addition to harming whales, such mid-frequency sonar has also been shown to harm dolphins, and may also harm turtles, fish and other marine life, according to the groups.

"Military sonar generates ear-splitting noise that can injure and even kill marine mammals," said Brosnan in a video made for one of the groups that brought the suit.

"Without reasonable limits, military sonar will cause excruciating pain and death," said Brosnan who was last week replaced as secret agent 007 in the famed movie series.

Related Links
SpaceDaily
Search SpaceDaily
Subscribe To SpaceDaily Express

Whales, Seals Used As Ocean Reporters
Tokyo (UPI) Sep 05, 2005
A Japanese university has begun attaching cameras and sensors to seals and whales as part of an investigation of the ocean environment.







  • Coast Guard Uses New Tech To Restore Communications Following Hurricanes
  • Analysis: Quake Largest U.N. Relief Effort
  • UCF Researchers To Develop Water Purification System For Hurricane Relief
  • UN Demands World Not Let Pakistan Quake Victims Die

  • Mountain Winds May Create Atmospheric Hotspots
  • Climate Model Predicts Dramatic Changes Over Next 100 Years
  • Warmer Seas, Wetter Air Make Harder Rains as Greenhouse Gases Build
  • Link Between Tropical Warming And Greenhouse Gases Stronger Than Ever

  • The Next Generation Blue Marble
  • Interview With Volker Liebig On The Loss Of Cryosat
  • Wetlands Satellite Mapping Scheme Yielding First Results
  • DigitalGlobe Unveils Plans For WorldView I And WorldView II Imaging Systems

  • Outside View: The Oil Tsunami
  • It Whistles; Change In Pitch Tells All In This New Sonic Gas Analyzer
  • Medis Receives General Dynamics Order For Next Phase Of Military Fuel Cell Research Program
  • Honda Unveils Hydrogen Fuel-Cell Concept Car

  • Creating DNA Vaccine Could Help Save Lives, Slow Spread Of 'Bird Flu'
  • Generic-Drug Companies To Produce Tamiflu
  • Expert: Don't Rely On Tamiflu For Bird Flu
  • China Reports New Bird Flu Outbreak As Pandemic Fears Grow

  • UCSD Study Shows 'Junk' DNA Has Evolutionary Importance
  • U. of Colorado Researcher Identifies Tracks Of Swimming Dinosaur In Wyoming
  • Creeping Crinoids! Sea Lilies Crawl To Escape Predators, Video Shows
  • Half-Animal, Half-Plant Microbe Found

  • Acid Rain And Forest Mass: Another Perspective
  • Mystery Fumes Envelope Lagos
  • Katrina Floodwaters Not As Toxic To Humans As Previously Thought, Study Says
  • UCSD Leads Team To Build Geographic Information System To Assess Toxic Hazards From Katrina

  • Ancient Anthropoid Origins Discovered In Africa
  • Scientists Uncover Why Picture Perception Works
  • The Roots Of Civilization Trace Back To ... Roots
  • The Mechanics Of Foot Travel

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement