Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. Earth Science News .

Subscribe free to our newsletters via your

Analysis: Can clean tech save the economy?

disclaimer: image is for illustration purposes only
by Rosalie Westenskow
Washington DC (UPI) Jan 08, 2009
As Congress begins discussions on a second stimulus package for the ailing U.S. economy, momentum is growing to use part of the money to create clean, American-made technology that would green energy at home and compete internationally.

A number of policymakers hope to green the nation's energy supply and create new jobs through measures in the next stimulus legislation, expected to be one of the top priorities for President-elect Barack Obama and the next Congress.

"By investing in green technology, we can create the jobs we need today to be competitive in the future," Sen. Benjamin Cardin, D-Md., said Wednesday at a briefing in the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee.

International competitiveness in the energy sector is essential for economic recovery because the market is so big, said John Doerr, a partner at Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, one of the top venture capital firms for clean energy technology.

"Going green may be the largest economic opportunity of the 21st century," he said. "It is the mother of all markets."

Doerr told senators Wednesday the United States doesn't currently lead the international marketplace producing and selling clean energy technology, citing a number of emerging renewable energy technologies his firm is financing.

"Notice the trend here," he said. "If you list today's top 30 companies in solar, wind and advanced batteries, American companies hold only six spots. That should be a warning to us all."

Doerr outlined a number of recommendations for the stimulus package and future legislation: Create a new national electricity grid to get more electricity from renewable sources to consumers; mandate that a certain percentage of electricity nationwide come from renewable sources; give utility companies incentives to increase efficiency; spend more money on research, development and deployment of green technologies; create a scholarship fund for students studying engineering; and place a price on carbon, either through a tax or a cap-and-trade scheme.

Debate currently rages over whether short-term attempts to boost green jobs can revitalize the economy without a nationwide price on carbon. Proponents say such price incentives are necessary to spark investment, while opponents argue federal tinkering with the market will write the economy's obituary.

TRADING EMISSIONS Congress has debated, and ultimately rejected, a number of cap-and-trade bills. If one does pass, it would cap total U.S. carbon emissions at a certain level and allot emissions shares to businesses and other entities, which could then sell their shares if they cut their emissions below the mandated level.

Significant opposition to a cap-and-trade program continues in the new Congress, and Republicans are not likely to support similar legislation this year, including Sen. James Inhofe, R-Okla., ranking member of the Environment and Public Works Committee.

"The cap-and-trade or carbon tax approaches are misguided," said Marc Morano, the committee's GOP spokesman. "Inhofe does not believe the way to create jobs is by killing more jobs," he said, adding that is what "would happen if the Senate passed such legislation."

CHARGING TO POLLUTE Proponents counter that without a price on carbon, small-scale attempts to green the energy sector and increase jobs in renewable energy will be equally small in their effect on the economy. That's because cheap, dirty technologies already exist, so the market won't provide opportunities for large-scale deployment of clean alternatives without a price incentive imposed by the government, said Thomas Friedman, author of the recent best-seller "Hot, Flat, and Crowded: Why We Need a Green Revolution -- And How It Can Renew America."

"Launching the green revolution without a price signal would be like trying to launch the Apollo space program if Southwest Airlines already flew to the moon," he said.

Opponents say a cap-and-trade program or other efforts to spur job growth through clean energy mandates would seriously damage the economy, outweighing any possible benefits. Even if such efforts create more green jobs, they're likely to have a negative effect on total employment numbers, said David Kreutzer, senior policy analyst in energy economics at The Heritage Foundation, a right-leaning think tank.

"When you divert $15 billion per year from some other part of the economy, you destroy jobs in that sector," Kreutzer told United Press International. "If you just look at the benefits, instead of the costs, anything looks good."

A cap-and-trade system or other mandates for renewable energy ultimately would raise energy costs, Kreutzer said, which is the exact opposite of what the government should do to address the nation's financial problems.

"One of the big contributors to the current economic crisis was the spike in energy costs over the past year," Kreutzer told UPI. "You want to keep energy costs low by adding to our energy supply, through (domestic) oil drilling, and not adding new regulations to industry that force them to use more costly forms of energy."

CLEAN COMPETITION One of the big concerns about a cap-and-trade system is its potential to stymie the competitiveness of U.S. companies, particularly if China and India don't pass similar laws. But its proponents say a cap-and-trade program would spur innovation, allowing the United States to outpace foreign competitors.

"I say to China, 'If you want to give America a five-year lead, God bless you. … Grow as dirty as you want, because we are going to clean your clock,'" Friedman told senators Wednesday.

It may not be that easy to monopolize the clean energy arena, though, particularly as China already is making significant advances in this area, said Jennifer Turner, director of the China Environment Forum at the Woodrow Wilson Center, a non-partisan research institution.

"China has actually done a lot in terms of energy efficiency," she said. For instance, "China is the largest producer and consumer of solar water heaters."

China, whose energy demands are huge and ever-increasing, certainly isn't waiting for the United States to take action, Turner told UPI.

"I think the Chinese have already said, 'We can't wait for these guys,'" Turner said. "So they're working with the Europeans and the Japanese right now."

"Creating a marketplace for clean energy technologies sends a signal to companies, and that encourages the development of these technologies, which, hopefully, you can export in the future," Will Pearson, global energy and natural resources analyst at the Eurasia Group, a global consulting firm, told UPI.

Because it's a long-term plan, though, Pearson said he projects cap-and-trade legislation will be delayed, while short-term fixes are implemented in the stimulus package.

"The main goal of the stimulus is to get people working," he said.

As a result, Pearson expects to see funding going into immediate job creation, including weatherization projects, increased funding for clean energy research and financing to build green technology infrastructure.

Share This Article With Planet Earth DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook

Related Links
The Economy

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Worldwide semiconductor sales fall in November
Washington (AFP) Jan 2, 2009
Worldwide semiconductor sales fell to 20.8 billion dollars in November, a decline of 9.8 percent compared with the same month last year, the Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) reported Friday.

  • More than 20 jailed over 2007 China bridge collapse: state media
  • Search halted, dozens still missing after deadly Guatemala landslide
  • Thousands flood refugee camps after strong Indonesia quakes
  • 33 dead in Guatemala landslide: rescue workers

  • Australian military warns of climate conflict: report
  • Despite deep chill, global warming is still a peril: scientists
  • Global Warming Aided By Drought, Deforestation Link
  • Some Climate Impacts Happening Faster Than Anticipated

  • Malaysia uses satellite to fight illegal logging: report
  • India To Launch Own Online Earth Browser Dubbed Bhuvan
  • New Satellite Data Reveal Impact Of Olympic Pollution Controls
  • Infoterra Supports Mapping For Dakar Rally With ERDAS Software

  • Analysis: Central Asian energy in 2009
  • Analysis: African oil faces challenges
  • New technique 'banks' wind farm energy
  • No breakthrough as Japan, China discuss gas field

  • China steps up checks after bird flu death
  • Death toll in Zimbabwe cholera epidemic at 1,732: WHO
  • China reassures over bird flu, says no outbreak
  • Zimbabwe cholera epidemic death toll stands at 1,778: WHO

  • Asian, US police meet on tackling wildlife crime
  • Pink iguanas discovered on Galapagos Islands
  • Protea Plants Help Unlock Secrets Of Species Hotspots
  • Quiet Bison Sire More Calves Than Louder Rivals

  • California Cuts Out The Waste At Landfills
  • 'Red tide' linked to nutrient pollution
  • 1 in 5 considering leaving Hong Kong due to pollution: survey
  • Hong Kong air pollution worst since records began: official data

  • Stevie Wonder looking for gadgets for the blind
  • How Neanderthal Got Whacked By Modern Humans
  • Proposed Texas science curriculum released
  • Competition may have done in Neanderthals

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement